握握弌傍利 > 凪麿窮徨慕 > prior analytics >

及22嫗

prior analytics-及22嫗

弌傍�� prior analytics 忖方�� 耽匈3500忖

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��






B。 Consequently�察�if this is impossible�察�A must belong to some B。 But



if it is supposed that A does not belong to some B�察�we shall have



the same results as in the first figure。



  Again suppose that A belongs to some B�察�and let A belong to no C。 It



is necessary then that C should not belong to some B。 But originally



it belonged to all B�察�consequently the hypothesis is false�此�A then



will belong to no B。



  When A does not belong to an B�察�suppose it does belong to all B�察�and



to no C。 It is necessary then that C should belong to no B。 But this



is impossible�此�so that it is true that A does not belong to all B。



It is clear then that all the syllogisms can be formed in the middle



figure。







                                13







  Similarly they can all be formed in the last figure。 Suppose that



A does not belong to some B�察�but C belongs to all B�此�then A does not



belong to some C。 If then this is impossible�察�it is false that A



does not belong to some B�察�so that it is true that A belongs to all B。



But if it is supposed that A belongs to no B�察�we shall have a



syllogism and a conclusion which is impossible�此�but the problem in



hand is not proved�此�for if the contrary is supposed�察�we shall have the



same results as before。



  But to prove that A belongs to some B�察�this hypothesis must be made。



If A belongs to no B�察�and C to some B�察�A will belong not to all C。



If then this is false�察�it is true that A belongs to some B。



  When A belongs to no B�察�suppose A belongs to some B�察�and let it have



been assumed that C belongs to all B。 Then it is necessary that A



should belong to some C。 But ex hypothesi it belongs to no C�察�so



that it is false that A belongs to some B。 But if it is supposed



that A belongs to all B�察�the problem is not proved。



  But this hypothesis must be made if we are prove that A belongs



not to all B。 For if A belongs to all B and C to some B�察�then A



belongs to some C。 But this we assumed not to be so�察�so it is false



that A belongs to all B。 But in that case it is true that A belongs



not to all B。 If however it is assumed that A belongs to some B�察�we



shall have the same result as before。



  It is clear then that in all the syllogisms which proceed per



impossibile the contradictory must be assumed。 And it is plain that in



the middle figure an affirmative conclusion�察�and in the last figure



a universal conclusion�察�are proved in a way。







                                14







  Demonstration per impossibile differs from ostensive proof in that



it posits what it wishes to refute by reduction to a statement



admitted to be false�察�whereas ostensive proof starts from admitted



positions。 Both�察�indeed�察�take two premisses that are admitted�察�but the



latter takes the premisses from which the syllogism starts�察�the former



takes one of these�察�along with the contradictory of the original



conclusion。 Also in the ostensive proof it is not necessary that the



conclusion should be known�察�nor that one should suppose beforehand



that it is true or not�此�in the other it is necessary to suppose



beforehand that it is not true。 It makes no difference whether the



conclusion is affirmative or negative�察�the method is the same in



both cases。 Everything which is concluded ostensively can be proved



per impossibile�察�and that which is proved per impossibile can be



proved ostensively�察�through the same terms。 Whenever the syllogism



is formed in the first figure�察�the truth will be found in the middle



or the last figure�察�if negative in the middle�察�if affirmative in the



last。 Whenever the syllogism is formed in the middle figure�察�the truth



will be found in the first�察�whatever the problem may be。 Whenever



the syllogism is formed in the last figure�察�the truth will be found in



the first and middle figures�察�if affirmative in first�察�if negative



in the middle。 Suppose that A has been proved to belong to no B�察�or



not to all B�察�through the first figure。 Then the hypothesis must



have been that A belongs to some B�察�and the original premisses that



C belongs to all A and to no B。 For thus the syllogism was made and



the impossible conclusion reached。 But this is the middle figure�察�if C



belongs to all A and to no B。 And it is clear from these premisses



that A belongs to no B。 Similarly if has been proved not to belong



to all B。 For the hypothesis is that A belongs to all B�察�and the



original premisses are that C belongs to all A but not to all B。



Similarly too�察�if the premiss CA should be negative�此�for thus also



we have the middle figure。 Again suppose it has been proved that A



belongs to some B。 The hypothesis here is that is that A belongs to no



B�察�and the original premisses that B belongs to all C�察�and A either to



all or to some C�此�for in this way we shall get what is impossible。 But



if A and B belong to all C�察�we have the last figure。 And it is clear



from these premisses that A must belong to some B。 Similarly if B or A



should be assumed to belong to some C。



  Again suppose it has been proved in the middle figure that A belongs



to all B。 Then the hypothesis must have been that A belongs not to all



B�察�and the original premisses that A belongs to all C�察�and C to all B��



for thus we shall get what is impossible。 But if A belongs to all C��



and C to all B�察�we have the first figure。 Similarly if it has been



proved that A belongs to some B�此�for the hypothesis then must have



been that A belongs to no B�察�and the original premisses that A belongs



to all C�察�and C to some B。 If the syllogism is negative�察�the



hypothesis must have been that A belongs to some B�察�and the original



premisses that A belongs to no C�察�and C to all B�察�so that the first



figure results。 If the syllogism is not universal�察�but proof has



been given that A does not belong to some B�察�we may infer in the



same way。 The hypothesis is that A belongs to all B�察�the original



premisses that A belongs to no C�察�and C belongs to some B�此�for thus we



get the first figure。



  Again suppose it has been proved in the third figure that A



belongs to all B。 Then the hypothesis must have been that A belongs



not to all B�察�and the original premisses that C belongs to all B��



and A belongs to all C�察�for thus we shall get what is impossible。



And the original premisses form the first figure。 Similarly if the



demonstration establishes a particular proposition�此�the hypothesis



then must have been that A belongs to no B�察�and the original premisses



that C belongs to some B�察�and A to all C。 If the syllogism is



negative�察�the hypothesis must have been that A belongs to some B��



and the original premisses that C belongs to no A and to all B�察�and



this is the middle figure。 Similarly if the demonstration is not



universal。 The hypothesis will then be that A belongs to all B�察�the



premisses that C belongs to no A and to some B�此�and this is the middle



figure。



  It is clear then that it is possible through the same terms to prove



each of the problems ostensively as well。 Similarly it will be



possible if the syllogisms are ostensive to reduce them ad impossibile



in the terms which have been taken�察�whenever the contradictory of



the conclusion of the ostensive syllogism is taken as a premiss。 For



the syllogisms become identical with those which are obtained by means



of conversion�察�so that we obtain immediately the figures through which



each problem will be solved。 It is clear then that every thesis can be



proved in both ways�察�i。e。 per impossibile and ostensively�察�and it is



not possible to separate one method from the other。







                                15







  In what figure it is possible to draw a conclusion from premisses



which are opposed�察�and in what figure this is not possible�察�will be



made clear in this way。 Verbally four kinds of opposition are



possible�察�viz。 universal affirmative to universal negative��



universal affirmative to particular negative�察�particular affirmative



to universal negative�察�and particular affirmative to particular



negative�此�but really there are only three�此�for the particular



affirmative is only verbally opposed to the particular negative。 Of



the genuine opposites I call those which are universal contraries�察�the



universal affirmative and the universal negative�察�e。g。 'every



science is good'�察�'no science is good'�察�the others I call



contradictories。



  In the first figure no syllogism whether affirmative or negative can



be made out of opposed premisses�此�no affirmative syllogism is possible



because both premisses must be affirmative�察�but opposites are�察�the one



affirmative�察�the other negative�此�no negative syllogism is possible



because opposites affirm and deny the same predicate of the same



subject�察�and the middle term in the first figure is not predicated



of both extremes�察�but one thing is denied of it�察�and it is affirmed of



something else�此�but such premisses are not opposed。



  In the middle figure a syllogism can be made both



oLcontradictories and of contraries。 Let A stand for good�察�let B and C



stand for science。 If then one assumes that every science is good�察�and



no science is good�察�A belongs to all B and to no C�察�so that B



belongs to no C�此�no science then is a science。 Similarly if after



taking 'every science is good' one took 'the science of medicine is



not good'�察�for A belongs to all B but to no C�察�so that a particular



science will not be a science。 Again�察�a particular science will not be



a science if A belongs to all C but to no B�察�and B is science�察�C



medicine�察�and A supposition�此�for after taking 'no science is



supposition'�察�one has assumed that a particular science is



supposition。 This syllogism differs from the preceding because the



relations between the terms are reversed�此�before�察�the affirmative



statement concerned B�察�now it concerns C。 Similarly if one premiss



is not universal�此�for the middle term is always that which is stated



negatively of one extreme�察�and affirmatively of the other。



Consequently it is possible that contradictories may lead to a



conclusion�察�though not always or in every mood�察�but only if the



terms subordinate to the middle are such that they are either



identical or related as whole to part。 Otherwise it is impossible�此�for



the premisses cannot anyhow be either contraries or contradictories。



  In the third figure an affirmative syllogism can never be made out



of opposite premisses�察�for the reason given in reference to th

卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��4�� 家��3��

低辛嬬浪散議