握握弌傍利 > 凪麿窮徨慕 > prior analytics >

及12嫗

prior analytics-及12嫗

弌傍�� prior analytics 忖方�� 耽匈3500忖

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��





consequently A will not belong to some of the Es。 If B is identical



with G�察�there will be a converted syllogism�此�for E will belong to



all A since B belongs to A and E to B ��for B was found to be identical



with G���此�but that A should belong to all E is not necessary�察�but it



must belong to some E because it is possible to convert the



universal statement into a particular。



  It is clear then that in every proposition which requires proof we



must look to the aforesaid relations of the subject and predicate in



question�此�for all syllogisms proceed through these。 But if we are



seeking consequents and antecedents we must look for those which are



primary and most universal�察�e。g。 in reference to E we must look to



KF rather than to F alone�察�and in reference to A we must look to KC



rather than to C alone。 For if A belongs to KF�察�it belongs both to F



and to E�此�but if it does not follow KF�察�it may yet follow F。 Similarly



we must consider the antecedents of A itself�此�for if a term follows



the primary antecedents�察�it will follow those also which are



subordinate�察�but if it does not follow the former�察�it may yet follow



the latter。



  It is clear too that the inquiry proceeds through the three terms



and the two premisses�察�and that all the syllogisms proceed through the



aforesaid figures。 For it is proved that A belongs to all E��



whenever an identical term is found among the Cs and Fs。 This will



be the middle term�察�A and E will be the extremes。 So the first



figure is formed。 And A will belong to some E�察�whenever C and G are



apprehended to be the same。 This is the last figure�此�for G becomes the



middle term。 And A will belong to no E�察�when D and F are identical。



Thus we have both the first figure and the middle figure�察�the first��



because A belongs to no F�察�since the negative statement is



convertible�察�and F belongs to all E�此�the middle figure because D



belongs to no A�察�and to all E。 And A will not belong to some E��



whenever D and G are identical。 This is the last figure�此�for A will



belong to no G�察�and E will belong to all G。 Clearly then all



syllogisms proceed through the aforesaid figures�察�and we must not



select consequents of all the terms�察�because no syllogism is



produced from them。 For ��as we saw�� it is not possible at all to



establish a proposition from consequents�察�and it is not possible to



refute by means of a consequent of both the terms in question�此�for the



middle term must belong to the one�察�and not belong to the other。



  It is clear too that other methods of inquiry by selection of middle



terms are useless to produce a syllogism�察�e。g。 if the consequents of



the terms in question are identical�察�or if the antecedents of A are



identical with those attributes which cannot possibly belong to E��



or if those attributes are identical which cannot belong to either



term�此�for no syllogism is produced by means of these。 For if the



consequents are identical�察�e。g。 B and F�察�we have the middle figure



with both premisses affirmative�此�if the antecedents of A are identical



with attributes which cannot belong to E�察�e。g。 C with H�察�we have the



first figure with its minor premiss negative。 If attributes which



cannot belong to either term are identical�察�e。g。 C and H�察�both



premisses are negative�察�either in the first or in the middle figure。



But no syllogism is possible in this way。



  It is evident too that we must find out which terms in this



inquiry are identical�察�not which are different or contrary�察�first



because the object of our investigation is the middle term�察�and the



middle term must be not diverse but identical。 Secondly�察�wherever it



happens that a syllogism results from taking contraries or terms which



cannot belong to the same thing�察�all arguments can be reduced to the



aforesaid moods�察�e。g。 if B and F are contraries or cannot belong to



the same thing。 For if these are taken�察�a syllogism will be formed



to prove that A belongs to none of the Es�察�not however from the



premisses taken but in the aforesaid mood。 For B will belong to all



A and to no E。 Consequently B must be identical with one of the Hs。



Again�察�if B and G cannot belong to the same thing�察�it follows that A



will not belong to some of the Es�此�for then too we shall have the



middle figure�此�for B will belong to all A and to no G。 Consequently



B must be identical with some of the Hs。 For the fact that B and G



cannot belong to the same thing differs in no way from the fact that B



is identical with some of the Hs�此�for that includes everything which



cannot belong to E。



  It is clear then that from the inquiries taken by themselves no



syllogism results�察�but if B and F are contraries B must be identical



with one of the Hs�察�and the syllogism results through these terms。



It turns out then that those who inquire in this manner are looking



gratuitously for some other way than the necessary way because they



have failed to observe the identity of the Bs with the Hs。







                                29







  Syllogisms which lead to impossible conclusions are similar to



ostensive syllogisms�察�they also are formed by means of the consequents



and antecedents of the terms in question。 In both cases the same



inquiry is involved。 For what is proved ostensively may also be



concluded syllogistically per impossibile by means of the same



terms�察�and what is proved per impossibile may also be proved



ostensively�察�e。g。 that A belongs to none of the Es。 For suppose A to



belong to some E�此�then since B belongs to all A and A to some of the



Es�察�B will belong to some of the Es�此�but it was assumed that it



belongs to none。 Again we may prove that A belongs to some E�此�for if A



belonged to none of the Es�察�and E belongs to all G�察�A will belong to



none of the Gs�此�but it was assumed to belong to all。 Similarly with



the other propositions requiring proof。 The proof per impossibile will



always and in all cases be from the consequents and antecedents of the



terms in question。 Whatever the problem the same inquiry is



necessary whether one wishes to use an ostensive syllogism or a



reduction to impossibility。 For both the demonstrations start from the



same terms�察�e。g。 suppose it has been proved that A belongs to no E��



because it turns out that otherwise B belongs to some of the Es and



this is impossible´if now it is assumed that B belongs to no E and



to all A�察�it is clear that A will belong to no E。 Again if it has been



proved by an ostensive syllogism that A belongs to no E�察�assume that A



belongs to some E and it will be proved per impossibile to belong to



no E。 Similarly with the rest。 In all cases it is necessary to find



some common term other than the subjects of inquiry�察�to which the



syllogism establishing the false conclusion may relate�察�so that if



this premiss is converted�察�and the other remains as it is�察�the



syllogism will be ostensive by means of the same terms。 For the



ostensive syllogism differs from the reductio ad impossibile in



this�此�in the ostensive syllogism both remisses are laid down in



accordance with the truth�察�in the reductio ad impossibile one of the



premisses is assumed falsely。



  These points will be made clearer by the sequel�察�when we discuss the



reduction to impossibility�此�at present this much must be clear�察�that



we must look to terms of the kinds mentioned whether we wish to use an



ostensive syllogism or a reduction to impossibility。 In the other



hypothetical syllogisms�察�I mean those which proceed by substitution��



or by positing a certain quality�察�the inquiry will be directed to



the terms of the problem to be proved´not the terms of the original



problem�察�but the new terms introduced�察�and the method of the inquiry



will be the same as before。 But we must consider and determine in



how many ways hypothetical syllogisms are possible。



  Each of the problems then can be proved in the manner described�察�but



it is possible to establish some of them syllogistically in another



way�察�e。g。 universal problems by the inquiry which leads up to a



particular conclusion�察�with the addition of an hypothesis。 For if



the Cs and the Gs should be identical�察�but E should be assumed to



belong to the Gs only�察�then A would belong to every E�此�and again if



the Ds and the Gs should be identical�察�but E should be predicated of



the Gs only�察�it follows that A will belong to none of the Es。



Clearly then we must consider the matter in this way also。 The



method is the same whether the relation is necessary or possible。



For the inquiry will be the same�察�and the syllogism will proceed



through terms arranged in the same order whether a possible or a



pure proposition is proved。 We must find in the case of possible



relations�察�as well as terms that belong�察�terms which can belong though



they actually do not�此�for we have proved that the syllogism which



establishes a possible relation proceeds through these terms as



well。 Similarly also with the other modes of predication。



  It is clear then from what has been said not only that all



syllogisms can be formed in this way�察�but also that they cannot be



formed in any other。 For every syllogism has been proved to be



formed through one of the aforementioned figures�察�and these cannot



be composed through other terms than the consequents and antecedents



of the terms in question�此�for from these we obtain the premisses and



find the middle term。 Consequently a syllogism cannot be formed by



means of other terms。







                                30







  The method is the same in all cases�察�in philosophy�察�in any art or



study。 We must look for the attributes and the subjects of both our



terms�察�and we must supply ourselves with as many of these as possible��



and consider them by means of the three terms�察�refuting statements



in one way�察�confirming them in another�察�in the pursuit of truth



starting from premisses in which the arrangement of the terms is in



accordance with truth�察�while if we look for dialectical syllogisms



we must start from probable premisses。 The principles of syllogisms



have been stated in general terms�察�both how they are characterized and



how we must hunt for them�察�so as not to look to everything that is



said about the terms of the problem or to the same points whether we



are confirming or refuting�察�or again whether we are confirming of



all or of some�察�and whether we are refuting of all or some。 we must



look to fewer points and they mus

卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��4�� 家��3��

低辛嬬浪散議