握握弌傍利 > 凪麿窮徨慕 > prior analytics >

及11嫗

prior analytics-及11嫗

弌傍�� prior analytics 忖方�� 耽匈3500忖

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��






Consequently the conclusions will be much more numerous than the terms



or the premisses。







                                26







  Since we understand the subjects with which syllogisms are



concerned�察�what sort of conclusion is established in each figure��



and in how many moods this is done�察�it is evident to us both what sort



of problem is difficult and what sort is easy to prove。 For that which



is concluded in many figures and through many moods is easier�察�that



which is concluded in few figures and through few moods is more



difficult to attempt。 The universal affirmative is proved by means



of the first figure only and by this in only one mood�察�the universal



negative is proved both through the first figure and through the



second�察�through the first in one mood�察�through the second in two。



The particular affirmative is proved through the first and through the



last figure�察�in one mood through the first�察�in three moods through the



last。 The particular negative is proved in all the figures�察�but once



in the first�察�in two moods in the second�察�in three moods in the third。



It is clear then that the universal affirmative is most difficult to



establish�察�most easy to overthrow。 In general�察�universals are easier



game for the destroyer than particulars�此�for whether the predicate



belongs to none or not to some�察�they are destroyed�此�and the particular



negative is proved in all the figures�察�the universal negative in



two。 Similarly with universal negatives�此�the original statement is



destroyed�察�whether the predicate belongs to all or to some�此�and this



we found possible in two figures。 But particular statements can be



refuted in one way only´by proving that the predicate belongs either



to all or to none。 But particular statements are easier to



establish�此�for proof is possible in more figures and through more



moods。 And in general we must not forget that it is possible to refute



statements by means of one another�察�I mean�察�universal statements by



means of particular�察�and particular statements by means of



universal�此�but it is not possible to establish universal statements by



means of particular�察�though it is possible to establish particular



statements by means of universal。 At the same time it is evident



that it is easier to refute than to establish。



  The manner in which every syllogism is produced�察�the number of the



terms and premisses through which it proceeds�察�the relation of the



premisses to one another�察�the character of the problem proved in



each figure�察�and the number of the figures appropriate to each



problem�察�all these matters are clear from what has been said。







                                27







  We must now state how we may ourselves always have a supply of



syllogisms in reference to the problem proposed and by what road we



may reach the principles relative to the problem�此�for perhaps we ought



not only to investigate the construction of syllogisms�察�but also to



have the power of making them。



  Of all the things which exist some are such that they cannot be



predicated of anything else truly and universally�察�e。g。 Cleon and



Callias�察�i。e。 the individual and sensible�察�but other things may be



predicated of them ��for each of these is both man and animal���察�and



some things are themselves predicated of others�察�but nothing prior



is predicated of them�察�and some are predicated of others�察�and yet



others of them�察�e。g。 man of Callias and animal of man。 It is clear



then that some things are naturally not stated of anything�此�for as a



rule each sensible thing is such that it cannot be predicated of



anything�察�save incidentally�此�for we sometimes say that that white



object is Socrates�察�or that that which approaches is Callias。 We shall



explain in another place that there is an upward limit also to the



process of predicating�此�for the present we must assume this。 Of



these ultimate predicates it is not possible to demonstrate another



predicate�察�save as a matter of opinion�察�but these may be predicated of



other things。 Neither can individuals be predicated of other things��



though other things can be predicated of them。 Whatever lies between



these limits can be spoken of in both ways�此�they may be stated of



others�察�and others stated of them。 And as a rule arguments and



inquiries are concerned with these things。 We must select the



premisses suitable to each problem in this manner�此�first we must lay



down the subject and the definitions and the properties of the



thing�察�next we must lay down those attributes which follow the



thing�察�and again those which the thing follows�察�and those which cannot



belong to it。 But those to which it cannot belong need not be



selected�察�because the negative statement implied above is convertible。



Of the attributes which follow we must distinguish those which fall



within the definition�察�those which are predicated as properties�察�and



those which are predicated as accidents�察�and of the latter those which



apparently and those which really belong。 The larger the supply a



man has of these�察�the more quickly will he reach a conclusion�察�and



in proportion as he apprehends those which are truer�察�the more



cogently will he demonstrate。 But he must select not those which



follow some particular but those which follow the thing as a whole��



e。g。 not what follows a particular man but what follows every man�此�for



the syllogism proceeds through universal premisses。 If the statement



is indefinite�察�it is uncertain whether the premiss is universal�察�but



if the statement is definite�察�the matter is clear。 Similarly one



must select those attributes which the subject follows as wholes��



for the reason given。 But that which follows one must not suppose to



follow as a whole�察�e。g。 that every animal follows man or every science



music�察�but only that it follows�察�without qualification�察�and indeed



we state it in a proposition�此�for the other statement is useless and



impossible�察�e。g。 that every man is every animal or justice is all



good。 But that which something follows receives the mark 'every'。



Whenever the subject�察�for which we must obtain the attributes that



follow�察�is contained by something else�察�what follows or does not



follow the highest term universally must not be selected in dealing



with the subordinate term ��for these attributes have been taken in



dealing with the superior term�察�for what follows animal also follows



man�察�and what does not belong to animal does not belong to man���察�but



we must choose those attributes which are peculiar to each subject。



For some things are peculiar to the species as distinct from the



genus�察�for species being distinct there must be attributes peculiar to



each。 Nor must we take as things which the superior term follows��



those things which the inferior term follows�察�e。g。 take as subjects of



the predicate 'animal' what are really subjects of the predicate



'man'。 It is necessary indeed�察�if animal follows man�察�that it should



follow all these also。 But these belong more properly to the choice of



what concerns man。 One must apprehend also normal consequents and



normal antecedents´�察�for propositions which obtain normally are



established syllogistically from premisses which obtain normally�察�some



if not all of them having this character of normality。 For the



conclusion of each syllogism resembles its principles。 We must not



however choose attributes which are consequent upon all the terms�此�for



no syllogism can be made out of such premisses。 The reason why this is



so will be clear in the sequel。







                                28







  If men wish to establish something about some whole�察�they must



look to the subjects of that which is being established ��the



subjects of which it happens to be asserted���察�and the attributes which



follow that of which it is to be predicated。 For if any of these



subjects is the same as any of these attributes�察�the attribute



originally in question must belong to the subject originally in



question。 But if the purpose is to establish not a universal but a



particular proposition�察�they must look for the terms of which the



terms in question are predicable�此�for if any of these are identical��



the attribute in question must belong to some of the subject in



question。 Whenever the one term has to belong to none of the other��



one must look to the consequents of the subject�察�and to those



attributes which cannot possibly be present in the predicate in



question�此�or conversely to the attributes which cannot possibly be



present in the subject�察�and to the consequents of the predicate。 If



any members of these groups are identical�察�one of the terms in



question cannot possibly belong to any of the other。 For sometimes a



syllogism in the first figure results�察�sometimes a syllogism in the



second。 But if the object is to establish a particular negative



proposition�察�we must find antecedents of the subject in question and



attributes which cannot possibly belong to the predicate in



question。 If any members of these two groups are identical�察�it follows



that one of the terms in question does not belong to some of the



other。 Perhaps each of these statements will become clearer in the



following way。 Suppose the consequents of A are designated by B�察�the



antecedents of A by C�察�attributes which cannot possibly belong to A by



D。 Suppose again that the attributes of E are designated by F�察�the



antecedents of E by G�察�and attributes which cannot belong to E by H。



If then one of the Cs should be identical with one of the Fs�察�A must



belong to all E�此�for F belongs to all E�察�and A to all C��



consequently A belongs to all E。 If C and G are identical�察�A must



belong to some of the Es�此�for A follows C�察�and E follows all G。 If F



and D are identical�察�A will belong to none of the Es by a



prosyllogism�此�for since the negative proposition is convertible�察�and F



is identical with D�察�A will belong to none of the Fs�察�but F belongs to



all E。 Again�察�if B and H are identical�察�A will belong to none of the



Es�此�for B will belong to all A�察�but to no E�此�for it was assumed to



be identical with H�察�and H belonged to none of the Es。 If D and G



are identical�察�A will not belong to some of the Es�此�for it will not



belong to G�察�because it does not belong to D�此�but G falls under E��



consequently A will not belong to some of the Es。 If B is identical



with G�察�there will be a converted syllogism�此�for E will belong to


卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��4�� 家��3��

低辛嬬浪散議