the ethics(part iv)-及9嫗
梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
his own power of activity�察�this is the same as saying that we conceive
that a man understands himself distinctly ��IV��xxvi。���察�because ��Land reads�此�
;Quod ipsius agendi potentia juvatur;´ which I have translated above。 He ´
suggests as alternative readings to `quod'�察�'quo' ��= whereby�� and 'quodque'
��= and that��。�� his power of activity is aided。 Wherefore humility�察�or the
pain which arises from a man's contemplation of his own infirmity�察�does
not arise from the contemplation or reason�察�and is not a virtue but a
passion。 Q。E。D。
Prop。 LIV。 Repentance is not a virtue�察�
or does not arise from reason �察�but he
who repents of an action is doubly
wretched or infirm。
Proof。´ The first part of this proposition is proved like the foregoing
one。 The second part is proved from the mere definition of the emotion in
question ��Def。 of the Emotions��xxvii。��。 For the man allows himself to be
overcome�察�first�察�by evil desires�察�secondly�察�by pain。
Note。´ As men seldom live under the guidance of reason�察�these two emotions�察�
namely�察�Humility and Repentance�察�as also Hope and Fear�察�bring more good
than harm�察�hence�察�as we must sin�察�we had better sin in that direction。
For�察�if all men who are a prey to emotion were all equally proud�察�they
would shrink from nothing�察�and would fear nothing�察�how then could they be
joined and linked together in bonds of union�拭 �The crowd plays the tyrant�察�
when it is not in fear�察�hence we need not wonder that the prophets�察�who
consulted the good�察�not of a few�察�but of all�察�so strenuously commended
Humility�察�Repentance�察�and Reverence。 Indeed those who are a prey to these
emotions may be led much more easily than others to live under the
guidance of reason�察�that is�察�to become free and to enjoy the life of the
blessed。
Prop。 LV。 Extreme pride or dejection
indicates extreme ignorance of self。
Proof。´ This is evident from Def。 of the Emotions��xxviii。 and xxix。
Prop。 LVI。 Extreme pride or dejection
indicates extreme infirmity of spirit。
Proof。´ The first foundation of virtue is self´preservation
��IV��xxii。Coroll。�� under the guidance of reason ��IV��xxiv。��。 He�察�therefore�察�
who is ignorant of himself�察�is ignorant of the foundation of all virtues�察�
and consequently of all virtues。 Again�察�to act virtuously is merely to
act under the guidance of reason ��IV��xxiv。���此�now he�察�that acts under the
guidance of reason�察�must necessarily know that he so acts ��III��xliii。��。
Therefore he who is in extreme ignorance of himself�察�and consequently of
all virtues�察�acts least in obedience to virtue�察�in other words
��IV��Def。viii。���察�is most infirm of spirit。 Thus extreme pride or dejection
indicates extreme infirmity of spirit。 Q。E。D。
Corollary。´ Hence it most clearly follows�察�that the proud and the
dejected specially fall a prey to the emotions。
Note。´ Yet dejection can be more easily corrected than pride�察�for the
latter being a pleasurable emotion�察�and the former a painful emotion�察�the
pleasurable is stronger than the painful ��IV��xviii。��。
Prop。 LVII。 The proud man delights in the
company of flatterers and parasites�察�
but hates the company of the high´minded。
Proof。´ Pride is pleasure arising from a man's over estimation of himself
��Def。 of the Emotions��xxviii。 and vi。���察�this estimation the proud man will
endeavour to foster by all the means in his power ��III��xiii。Note���察�he will
therefore delight in the company of flatterers and parasites ��whose
character is too well known to need definition here���察�and will avoid the
company of high´minded men�察�who value him according to his deserts。 Q。E。D。
Note。´ It would be too long a task to enumerate here all the evil results
of pride�察�inasmuch as the proud are a�察�prey to all the emotions�察�though to
none of them less than to love and pity。 I cannot�察�however�察�pass over in
silence the fact�察�that a man may be called proud from his underestimation
of other people�察�and�察�therefore�察�pride in this sense may be defined as
pleasure arising from the false opinion�察�whereby a man may consider
himself superior to his fellows。 The dejection�察�which is the opposite
quality to this sort of pride�察�may be defined as pain arising from the
false opinion�察�whereby a man may think himself inferior to his fellows。
Such being the ease�察�we can easily see that a proud man is necessarily
envious ��III��xli。Note���察�and only takes pleasure in the company�察�who fool
his weak mind to the top of his bent�察�and make him insane instead of
merely foolish。
Though dejection is the emotion contrary to pride�察�yet is the dejected
man very near akin to the proud man。 For�察�inasmuch as his pain arises
from a comparison between his own infirmity and other men's power or
virtue�察�it will be removed�察�or�察�in other words�察�he will feel pleasure�察�if
his imagination be occupied in contemplating other men's faults�察�whence
arises the proverb�察 �The unhappy are comforted by finding fellow´sufferers。;
Contrariwise�察�he will be the more pained in proportion as he thinks
himself inferior to others�察�hence none are so prone to envy as the
dejected�察�they are specially keen in observing men's actions�察�with a
view to fault´finding rather than correction�察�in order to reserve their
praises for dejection�察�and to glory therein�察�though all the time with a
dejected air。 These effects follow as necessarily from the said emotion�察�
as it follows from the nature of a triangle�察�that the three angles are
equal to two right angles。 I have already said that I call these and
similar emotions bad�察�solely in respect to what is useful to man。 The
laws of nature have regard to nature's general order�察�whereof man is but
a part。 I mention this�察�in passing�察�lest any should think that I have
wished to set forth the faults and irrational deeds of men rather than
the nature and properties of things。 For�察�as I said in the preface to the
third Part�察�I regard human emotions and their properties as on the same
footing with other natural phenomena。 Assuredly human emotions indicate
the power and ingenuity�察�of nature�察�if not of human nature�察�quite as fully�察�
as other things which we admire�察�and which we delight to contemplate。
But I pass on to note those qualities in the emotions�察�which bring
advantage to man�察�or inflict injury upon him。
Prop。 LVIII。 Honour ��gloria�� is not repugnant
to reason�察�but may arise therefrom。
Proof。´This is evident from Def。 of the Emotions��xxx。�察�and also from the
definition of an honourable man ��IV��xxxvii。Note。i。��。
Note。´ Empty honour�察�as it is styled�察�is self´ approval�察�fostered only by
the good opinion of the populace�察�when this good opinion ceases there
ceases also the self´approval�察�in other words�察�the highest object of each
man's love ��IV��lii。Note���察�consequently�察�he whose honour is rooted in
popular approval must�察�day by day�察�anxiously strive�察�act�察�and scheme in
order to retain his reputation。 For the populace is variable and
inconstant�察�so that�察�if a reputation be not kept up�察�it quickly withers
away。 Everyone wishes to catch popular applause for himself�察�and readily
represses the fame of others。 The object of the strife being estimated as
the greatest of all goods�察�each combatant is seized with a fierce desire
to put down his rivals in every possible way�察�till he who at last comes
out victorious is more proud of having done harm to others than of having
done good to himself。 This sort of honour�察�then�察�is really empty�察�being
nothing。
The points to note concerning shame ��pudor�� may easily be inferred
from what was said on the subject of mercy and repentance。 I will only
add that shame�察�like compassion�察�though not a virtue�察�is yet good�察�in so
far as it shows�察�that the feeler of shame is really imbued with the
desire to live honourably�察�in the same way as suffering is good�察�as
showing that the injured part is not mortified。 Therefore�察�though a man
who feels shame is sorrowful�察�he is yet more perfect than he�察�who is
shameless�察�and has no desire to live honourably。
Such are the points which I undertook to remark upon concerning the
emotions of pleasure and pain�察�as for the desires�察�they are good or bad
according as they spring from good or evil emotions。 But all�察�in so far
as they are engendered in us by�察�emotions wherein the mind is passive�察�
are blind ��as is evident from what was said in IV��xliv。Note���察�and would
be useless�察�if men could easily�察�be induced to live by the guidance of
reason only�察�as I will now briefly�察�show。
Prop。 LIX。 To all the actions�察�whereto we
are determined by emotion wherein the mind
is passive�察�we can be determined without
emotion by reason。
Proof。´ To act rationally�察�is nothing else ��III��iii。 and III��Def。ii。��
but to perform those actions�察�which follow from the necessity�察�of our
nature ��to persist�� considered in itself alone。 But pain is bad�察�in so
far as it diminishes or checks the power of action ��IV��xli。���察�wherefore
we cannot by pain be determined to any action�察�which we should be unable
to perform under the guidance of reason。 Again�察�pleasure is bad only
in so far as it hinders a man's capability for action ��IV��xli。�察�IV��xliii。���察�
therefore to this extent we could not be determined by�察�it to any action�察�
which we could not perform under the guidance of reason。 Lastly�察�pleasure�察�
in so far as it is good�察�is in harmony with reason ��for it consists in the
fact that a man's capability for action is increased or aided���察�nor is the
mind passive therein�察�except in so far as a man's power of action is not
increased to the extent of affording him an adequate conception of
himself and his actions ��III��iii。�察�&Note��。
Wherefore�察�if a man who is pleasurably affected be brought to such a
state of perfection�察�that he gains an adequate conception of himself and
his own actions�察�he will be equally�察�nay more�察�capable of those actions�察�
to which he is determined by emotion wherein the mind is passive。 But all
emotions are attributable to pleasure�察�to pain�察�or to desire ��Def。 of the
Emotions��iv。 explanation���察�and desire ��Def。 of the Emotions��i。�� is nothing
else but the attempt to act�察�therefore�察�to all actions�察�&c。 Q。E。D。
Another Proof。´ A given action is called bad�察�in so far as it arises
from one being affected by hatred or any evil emotion。 But no action�察�
considered in itself alone�察�is either good or bad ��as we pointed out in
the preface to Pt。 IV。���察�one and the same action being sometimes good�察�
sometimes bad�察�wherefo