the ethics(part iv)-及11嫗
梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
we shall readily see the difference between a man�察�who is led solely by
emotion or opinion�察�and a man�察�who is led by reason。 The former�察�whether
will or no�察�performs actions whereof he is utterly ignorant�察�the latter is
his own master and only performs such actions�察�as he knows are of primary
importance in life�察�and therefore chiefly�察�desires�察�wherefore I call the
former a slave�察�and the latter a free man�察�concerning whose disposition
and manner of life it will be well to make a few observations。
Prop。 LXVII。 A free man thinks of death
least of all things�察�and his wisdom is
a meditation not of death but of life。
Proof。´ A free man is one who lives under the guidance of reason�察�who is
not led by fear ��IV��lxiii。���察�but who directly desires that which is good
��IV��lxiii。Coroll。���察�in other words ��IV��xxiv。���察�who strives to act�察�to live�察�
and to preserve his being on the basis of seeking his own true advantage�察�
wherefore such an one thinks of nothing less than of death�察�but his wisdom
is a meditation of life。 Q。E。D
Prop。 LXVIII。 If men were born free�察�
they would�察�so long as they remained free�察�
form no conception of good and evil。
Proof。´ I call free him who is led solely by reason�察�he�察�therefore�察�who
is born free�察�and who remains free�察�has only adequate ideas�察�therefore
��IV��lxiv。Coroll。�� he has no conception of evil�察�or consequently ��good
and evil being correlative�� of good。 Q。E。D。
Note。´ It is evident�察�from IV��iv。�察�that the hypothesis of this Proposition
is false and inconceivable�察�except in so far as we look solely to the
nature of man�察�or rather to God�察�not in so far as the latter is infinite�察�
but only in so far as he is the cause of man's existence。
This�察�and other matters which we have already proved�察�seem to have
been signifieded by Moses in the history of the first man。 For in that
narrative no other power of God is conceived�察�save that whereby he
created man�察�that is the power wherewith he provided solely for man's
advantage�察�it is stated that God forbade man�察�being free�察�to eat of the
tree of the knowledge of good and evil�察�and that�察�as soon as man should
have eaten of it�察�he would straightway fear death rather than desire to
live。 Further�察�it is written that when man had found a wife�察�who was in
entire harmony with his nature�察�he knew that there could be nothing in
nature which could be more useful to him�察�but that after he believed the
beasts to be like himself�察�he straightway began to imitate their emotions
��III��xxvii。���察�and to lose his freedom�察�this freedom was afterwards
recovered by the patriarchs�察�led by the spirit of Christ�察�that is�察�by the
idea of God�察�whereon alone it depends�察�that man may be free�察�and desire for
others the good which he desires for himself�察�as we have shown above
��IV��xxxii。��。
Prop。 LXIX。 The virtue of a free man is seen
to be as great�察�when it declines dangers�察�
as when it overcomes them。
Proof。´ Emotion can only be checked or removed by an emotion contrary to
itself�察�and possessing more power in restraining emotion ��IV��vii。��。 But
blind daring and fear are emotions�察�which can be conceived as equally
great ��IV��v。 and IV��iii。���此�hence�察�no less virtue or firmness is required
in checking daring than in checking fear ��III��lix。Note���察�in other words
��Def。 of the Emotions��xl。 and xli。���察�the free man shows as much virtue�察�
when he declines dangers�察�as when he strives to overcome them。 Q。E。D。
Corollary。´ The free man is as courageous in timely retreat as in combat�察�
or�察�a free man shows equal courage or presence of mind�察�whether he elect
to give battle or to retreat。
Note。´ What courage ��animositas�� is�察�and what I mean thereby�察�I explained
in III��lix。Note。 By danger I mean everything�察�which can give rise to any
evil�察�such as pain�察�hatred�察�discord�察�&c。
Prop。 LXX。 The free man�察�who lives among the
ignorant�察�strives�察�as far as he can�察�to avoid
receiving favours from them。
Proof。´ Everyone judges what is good according to his disposition
��III��xxxix。Note���察�wherefore an ignorant man�察�who has conferred a benefit
on another�察�puts his own estimate upon it�察�and�察�if it appears to be
estimated less highly by the receiver�察�will feel pain ��III��xlii。��。 But
the free man only desires to join other men to him in friendship
��IV��xxxvii。���察�not repaying their benefits with others reckoned as of like
value�察�but guiding himself and others by the free decision of reason�察�
and doing only such things as he knows to be of primary importance。
Therefore the free man�察�lest be should become hateful to the ignorant�察�or
follow their desires rather than reason�察�will endeavour�察�as far as he can�察�
to avoid receiving their favours。
Note。´ I say�察�as far as he can。 For though men be ignorant�察�yet are they
men�察�and in cases of necessity could afford us human aid�察�the most
excellent of all things�此�therefore it is often necessary to accept favours
from them�察�and consequently to repay such favours in kind�察�we must�察�
therefore�察�exercise caution in declining favours�察�lest we should have the
appearance of despising those who bestow them�察�or of being�察�from
avaricious motives�察�unwilling to requite them�察�and so give ground for
offence by the very fact of striving to avoid it。 Thus�察�in declining
favours�察�we must look to the requirements of utility and courtesy。
Prop。 LXXI。 Only free men are thoroughly
grateful one to another。
Proof。´ Only free men are thoroughly useful one to another�察�and
associated among themselves by the closest necessity of friendship
��IV��xxxv。��&Coroll。i。���察�only such men endeavour�察�with mutual zeal of
love�察�to confer benefits on each other ��IV��xxxvii。���察�and�察�therefore�察�
only they are thoroughly grateful one to another。 Q。E。D。
Note。´ The goodwill�察�which men who are led by blind desire have for one
another�察�is generally a bargaining or enticement�察�rather than pure goodwill。
Moreover�察�ingratitude is not an emotion。 Yet it is base�察�inasmuch as
it generally shows�察�that a man is affected by excessive hatred�察�anger�察�
pride�察�avarice�察�&c。 He who�察�by reason of his folly�察�knows not how to
return benefits�察�is not ungrateful�察�much less he who is not gained over
by the gifts of a courtesan to serve her lust�察�or by a thief to conceal
his thefts�察�or by any similar persons。 Contrariwise�察�such an one shows
a constant mind�察�inasmuch as he cannot by an gifts be corrupted�察�to his
own or the general hurt。
Prop。 LXXII。 The free man never acts fraudulently�察�
but always in good faith。
Proof。´ If it be asked�此�What should a man's conduct be in a case where
he could by breaking faith free himself from the danger of present death�拭�
Would not his plan of self´preservation completely persuade him to deceive�拭�
This may be answered by pointing out that�察�if reason persuaded him to act
thus�察�it would persuade all men to act in a similar manner�察�in which case
reason would persuade men not to agree in good faith to unite their forces�察�
or to have laws in common�察�that is�察�not to。 have any general laws�察�which is
absurd。
Prop。 LXXIII。 The man�察�who is guided by reason�察�
is more free in a State�察�where he lives under
a general system of law�察�than in
solitude�察�where he is independent。
Proof。´ The man�察�who is guided by reason�察�does not obey through fear
��IV��Ixiii。���此�but�察�in so far as he endeavours to preserve his being
according to the dictates of reason�察�that is ��IV��lxvi。Note���察�in so far
as he endeavours to live in freedom�察�he desires to order his life
according to the general good ��IV��xxxvii。���察�and�察�consequently ��as we
showed in IV��xxxvii。Note。ii。���察�to live according to the laws of his
country。 Therefore the free man�察�in order to enjoy greater freedom�察�
desires to possess the general rights of citizenship。 Q。E。D。
Note。´ These and similar observations�察�which we have made on man's true
freedom�察�may be referred to strength�察�that is�察�to courage and nobility
of character ��III��lix。Note��。 I do not think it worth while to prove
separately all the properties of strength�察�much less need I show�察�that he
that is strong hates no man�察�is angry with no man�察�envies no man�察�is
indignant with no man�察�despises no man�察�and least of all things is proud。
These propositions�察�and all that relate to the true way of life and
religion�察�are easily proved from IV��xxxvii。 and IV��xlvi。�察�namely�察�that
hatred should be overcome with love�察�and that every man should desire for
others the good which he seeks for himself。 We may also repeat what
we drew attention to in the note to IV��I。�察�and in other places�察�namely�察�
that the strong man has ever first in his thoughts�察�that all things
follow from the necessity of the divine nature�察�so that whatsoever he
deems to be hurtful and evil�察�and whatsoever�察�accordingly�察�seems to him
impious�察�horrible�察�unjust�察�and base�察�assumes that appearance owing to his
own disordered�察�fragmentary�察�and confused view of the universe。 Wherefore
he strives before all things to conceive things as they really are�察�and
to remove the hindrances to true knowledge�察�such as are hatred�察�anger�察�
envy�察�derision�察�pride�察�and similar emotions�察�which I have mentioned above。
Thus he endeavours�察�as we said before�察�as far as in him lies�察�to do good�察�
and to go on his way rejoicing。 How far human virtue is capable of
attaining to such a condition�察�and what its powers may be�察�I will prove
in the following Part。
APPENDIX。
What have said in this Part concerning the right way of life has not been
arranged�察�so as to admit of being seen at one view�察�but has been set forth
piece´meal�察�according as I thought each Proposition could most readily be
deduced from what preceded it。 I propose�察�therefore�察�to rearrange my
remarks and to bring them under leading heads。
I。 All our endeavours or desires so follow from the necessity of our
nature�察�that they can be understood either through it alone�察�as their
proximate cause�察�or by virtue of our being a part of nature�察�which cannot
be adequately conceived through itself without other individuals。
II。 Desires�察�which follow from our nature in such a manner�察�that they can
be understood through it alone�察�are those which are referred to the mind�察�
in so far as the latter is conceived to consist of adequate ideas�此�the
remaining desires are only referred to the mind�察�in so far as it conceives
things inadequately�察�and their force and increase are generally defined
not by