握握弌傍利 > 凪麿窮徨慕 > alexandria and her schools(冉煽表寄才慢議僥丕) >

及7嫗

alexandria and her schools(冉煽表寄才慢議僥丕)-及7嫗

弌傍�� alexandria and her schools(冉煽表寄才慢議僥丕) 忖方�� 耽匈3500忖

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��




before   modern   discoveries。        But   its   value   as   a   scientific   attempt   lies   in 

this�此  �that the method being a correct one�察�correct results were obtained�察�

though      starting   from     a  false   assumption�察      �and   Hipparchus       and    his 



                                                24 


´ Page 25´

                            ALEXANDRIA AND HER SCHOOLS 



successors were enabled by it to calculate and predict the changes of the 

heavens�察     �in  spite   of  their   clumsy     instruments�察    �with   almost    as   much 

accuracy as we do now。 

     For   the   purpose   of   working   out   this   theory   he   required   a   science   of 

trigonometry�察�plane and spherical�此           �and this he accordingly seems to have 

invented。      To him also we owe the discovery of that vast gradual change 

in the position of the fixed stars�察�in fact�察�of the whole celestial system�察�now 

known   by   the   name   of   the   precession   of   the   equinoxes�察  �the   first   great 

catalogue   of   fixed   stars�察  �to   the   number   of   1080�察  �attempts   to   ascertain 

whether the length of years and days were constant�察�with which�察�with his 

characteristic love of truth�察�he seems to   have been hardly  satisfied。                  He 

too invented the planisphere�察�or mode of representing the starry heavens 

upon a plane�察�and is the father of true geography�察�having formed the happy 

notion   of   mapping   out   the   earth�察  �as   well   as   the   heavens�察  �by   degrees   of 

latitude and longitude。 

     Strange it is�察�and somewhat sad�察�that we should know nothing of this 

great   man�察  �should   be   hardly   able   to   distinguish   him   from   others   of   the 

same   name�察  �but   through   the   works   of   a   commentator�察  �who   wrote   and 

observed in Alexandria 300 years after�察�during the age of the Antonines。 I 

mean�察    �of  course�察   �the   famous    Ptolemy�察    �whose     name    so   long   bore   the 

honour of that system which really belonged to Hipparchus。 

     This   single   fact   speaks   volumes   for   the   real   weakness   of   the   great 

artificial school of literature and science founded by the kings of Egypt。 

From the father of Astronomy�察�as Delambre calls him�察�to Ptolemy�察�the first 

man who seems really to have appreciated him�察�we have not a discovery�察�

hardly   an   observation   or   a   name�察  �to   fill   the   gap。 Physical   sages   there 

were�察�but they were geometers and mathematicians�察�rather than astronomic 

observers   and   inquirers。       And   in   spite   of   all   the   huge   appliances   and 

advantages of that great Museum�察�its inhabitants were content�察�in physical 

science�察�as in all other branches of thought�察�to comment�察�to expound�察�to do 

everything but open their eyes and observe facts�察�and learn from them�察�as 

the predecessors whom they pretended to honour had done。                        But so it is 

always。      A genius�察�an original man appears。              He puts himself boldly in 

contact   with   facts�察  �asks   them   what   they   mean�察  �and   writes   down   their 



                                                25 


´ Page 26´

                             ALEXANDRIA AND HER SCHOOLS 



answer   for   the   world's   use。     And   then   his   disciples   must   needs   form   a 

school�察  �and   a   system�察  �and   fancy   that   they   do   honour   to   their   master   by 

refusing to follow in his steps�察�by making his book a fixed dogmatic canon�察�

attaching to it some magical infallibility�察�declaring the very lie which he 

disproved by his whole existence�察�that discovery is henceforth impossible�察�

and the sum of knowledge complete�此                 �instead of going on to discover as 

he discovered before them�察�and in following his method�察�show that they 

honour him�察�not in the letter�察�but in spirit and in truth。 

     For    this�察  �if  you   will   consider�察   �is  the   true   meaning      of  that   great 

command�察 �Honour thy father and mother�察�that thy days   may be long in 

the land。;      On reverence for the authority of bygone generations depends 

the permanence of every form of thought or belief�察�as much as of all social�察�

national�察�and family life�此        �but on reverence of the spirit�察�not merely of the 

letter�察  �of   the   methods   of   our   ancestors�察  �not   merely   of   their   conclusions。 

Ay�察  �and   we   shall   not   be   able   to   preserve   their   conclusions�察  �not   even   to 

understand them�察�they will die away on our lips into skeleton notions�察�and 

soulless phrases�察�unless we see that the greatness of the mighty dead has 

always   consisted   in   this�察  �that   they   were   seekers�察  �improvers�察  �inventors�察�

endued   with   that   divine   power   and   right   of   discovery   which   has   been 

bestowed   on   us�察  �even   as   on   them�察  �unless   we   become   such   men   as   they 

were�察�and go on to cultivate and develop the precious heritage which they 

have   bequeathed   to   us�察  �instead   of   hiding   their   talent   in     a   napkin    and 

burying   it   in   the   earth�察  �making   their   greatness   an   excuse   for   our   own 

littleness�察  �their   industry   for   our   laziness�察  �their   faith   for   our   despair�察  �and 

prating about the old paths�察�while we forget that paths were made that men 

might walk in them�察�and not stand still�察�and try in vain to stop the way。 

     It may be said�察�certainly�察�as an excuse for these Alexandrian Greeks�察�

that they were a people in a state of old age and decay�察�and that they only 

exhibited      the   common       and    natural    faults   of  old   age。     For    as   with 

individuals�察�so with races�察�nations�察�societies�察�schools of thought youth is 

the time of free fancy and poetry�察�manhood of calm and strong induction�察�

old age of deduction�察�when men settle down upon their lees�察�and content 

themselves with reaffirming and verifying the conclusions of their earlier 

years�察�and too often�察�alas� �with denying and anathematising all conclusions 



                                                 26 


´ Page 27´

                             ALEXANDRIA AND HER SCHOOLS 



which have been arrived at since their own meridian。                     It is sad�此   �but it is 

patent and common。            It is sad to think that the day may come to each of 

us�察  �when   we   shall   have   ceased   to   hope   for   discovery   and   for   progress�察�

when a thing will seem e priori false to us�察�simply because it is new�察�and 

we shall be saying querulously to the Divine Light which lightens every 

man     who     comes    into   the   world�此     �Hitherto     shalt   thou    come�察   �and    no 

further。     Thou   hast   taught   men   enough�察  �yea   rather�察  �thou   hast   exhausted 

thine   own   infinitude�察  �and   hast   no   more   to   teach   them。;      Surely   such   a 

temper is to be fought against�察�prayed against�察�both in ourselves�察�and in the 

generation      in   which    we    live。   Surely   there     is  no   reason    why   such    a 

temper  should   overtake   old   age。         There   may  be   reason   enough�察   �in   the 

nature of things。;        For that which is of nature is born only to decay and 

die。   But   in   man   there   is   more   than   dying   nature�察  �there   is   spirit�察  �and   a 

capability of spiritual and everlasting life�察�which renews its youth like the 

eagle's�察  �and   goes   on   from   strength   to   strength�察  �and   which�察  �if   it   have   its 

autumns       and    its  winters�察   �has   no    less   its  ever´recurring      springs    and 

summers�察�if it has its Sabbaths�察�finds in them only rest and refreshment for 

coming   labour。        And   why   not   in   nations�察  �societies�察  �scientific   schools�拭�

These too are not merely natural�此              �they are spiritual�察�and are only living 

and   healthy  in   as   far   as   they  are   in   harmony  with   spiritual�察  �unseen�察  �and 

everlasting      laws    of   God。     May      not   they�察  �too�察  �have    a   capability    of 

everlasting life�察�as long as they obey those laws in faith�察�and patience�察�and 

humility�拭      �We cannot deny the analogy between the individual man and 

these   societies   of   men。     We   cannot�察  �at   least�察  �deny  the   analogy   between 

them in growth�察�decay�察�and death。                May  we not have hope that it holds 

good also for that which can never die�察�and that if they do die�察�as this old 

Greek   society   did�察  �it   is   by   no   brute   natural   necessity�察  �but   by   their   own 

unfaithfulness to that which they knew�察�to that which they ought to have 

known�拭      �It is always more hopeful�察�always�察�as I think�察�more philosophic�察�

to throw the blame of failure on man�察�on our own selves�察�rather than on 

God�察  �and   the   perfect   law   of   His   universe。      At   least   let   us   be   sure   for 

ourselves�察�that such an old age as befell this Greek society�察�as befalls many 

a man nowadays�察�need not be our lot。                Let us be sure that earth shows no 

fairer sight   than   the   old   man�察  �whose   worn´out   brain   and   nerves   make   it 



                                                  27 


´ Page 28´

                            ALEXANDRIA AND HER SCHOOLS 



painful�察  �and   perhaps   impossible�察  �to   produce   fresh   thought   himself�此       �but 

who can yet welcome smilingly and joyfully the fresh thoughts of others�察�

who   keeps   unwearied   his   faith   in   God's   government   of   the   universe�察  �in 

God's continual education of the human race�察�who draws around him the 

young   and   the   sanguine�察  �not   merely   to   check   their   rashness   by  his   wise 

cautions�察    �but   to  inspirit  their  sloth   by   the  memories      of   his  own    past 

victories�察�who hands over�察�without envy or repining�察�the lamp of truth to 

younger   runners   than   himself�察  �and   sits   contented   by�察  �bidding   the   new 

generation God speed along the paths untrodden by him�察�but seen afar off 

by faith。     A few such old persons have I seen�察�both men and women�察�in 

whom   the   young   heart       beat   pure   and   fresh�察  �beneath   the   cautious    and 

practised brain of age�察�and gray hairs which were indeed a crown of glory。 

A few such have I seen�察�and from them I seemed to learn what was the 

likeness   of   our   Father   who   is   in   heaven。   To   such   an   old   age   may   He 

bring you and me�察�and all for whom we are bound to pray。 



                                                28 


´ Page 29´

                           ALEXANDRIA AND HER SCHOOLS 



      LECTURE IITHE PTOLEMAIC 

                        ERA ��Continued。�� 



     I said in my first Lecture�察�that even if royal influence be profitable for 

the prosecution of physical science�察�it cannot be profitable for

卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��1�� 家��2��

低辛嬬浪散議