握握弌傍利 > 凪麿窮徨慕 > history of the mackenzies >

及3嫗

history of the mackenzies-及3嫗

弌傍�� history of the mackenzies 忖方�� 耽匈3500忖

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��



icto Colino�察�et ejus successoribus to/as terras de Kintail Tenendas de nabis et  successoribus nostris in liberam baronium cum g ua rdia Reddendo  servicium fo rinsecum et fidelitatem Testibus Andrea episcopo�察 �Moraviensi。 Wa ltero Stewart。 Hen rico de Balioth Camerario。 Ama/do de  Campania。 Thoma Hostiario�察�vice´comite de Innerness。 Apud Kincardine�察 �IX die Jan。。 Anno Regni Domini�察�Regis XVI。;

This is a literal translation of the document。;Alexander�察�by the Grace of God�察�King of Scots�察�to all honest men  of his whole dominions�察�cleric and laic�察�greeting�此�Be it known to the  present and future that I�察�for the faithful service rendered to me by Colin of Ireland�察�in war as well as peace�察�therefore I have given�察�and by this my  present charter I concede to the said Colin and his successors�察�the lands of  Kintail to be held of us in free barony with ward to render foreign service  and fidelity。 Witnesses ��as above。�� At Kincardine�察�9th day of January�察�in the year of the reign of the Lord the King。 the 16th。;

The Kincardine at which this charter is alleged to have been signed is supposed to be the place of that name situated on the River Dee�察�for  about this time an incident is reported to have occurred in the Forest of Mar in connection with which it is traditionally stated that the Mackenzies  adopted the stag's head as their coat armour。  The legend is as follows��

Alexander was on a hunting expedition in the forest�察�near Kincardine�察�when an infuriated stag�察�closely pursued by the hounds�察�made straight in  the direction of the King�察�and Cailean Fitzgerald�察�who accompanied the  Royal party�察�gallantly interposed his own person between the exasperated  animal and his Majesty�察�and shot it with an arrow in the forehead。  The  King in acknowledgment of the Royal gratitude at once issued a diploma  in favour of Colin granting him armorial bearings which were to be�察�a  stags head puissant�察�bleeding at the forehead where the arrow pierced it�察�to  be borne on a field azure�察�supported by two greyhounds。  The crest to be a dexter arm bearing a naked sword�察�surrounded by the motto ;Fide Parta�察 �Fide Acta�察─�which continued to be the distinctive bearings of the  Mackenzies of Seaforth until it was considered expedient�察�as  corroborating their claims on the extensive possessions of the Macleods of  Lewis�察�to substitute for the original the crest of that warlike clan�察�namely�察 �a mountain in flames�察�surcharged with the words�察 �Luceo non uro�察─�the  ancient shield�察�supported by two savages�察�naked�察�and wreathed about the  head with laurel�察�armed with clubs issuing fire�察�which are the bearings  now used by the representatives of the High Chiefs of Kintail。  The incident of the hunting match and Colin Fitzgerald's gallant  rescue of Alexander III。 was painted by West for ;The last of the  Seaforths; in one of those large pictures with which the old Academician  employed and gratified his latter years。  The artist received ��oo for the noble painting�察�which is still preserved in Brahan Castle�察�and in his old age he expressed his willingness to give the same sum for it in order to  have it exhibited in his own collection。

The first notice of the reputed charter to Colin Fitzgerald is in the  manuscript history of the Mackenzies�察�by George�察�first Earl of Cromartie�察�already quoted�察�written about the middle of the seventeenth century。  All the later genealogists appear to have taken its authenticity for granted�察�and  quoted it accordingly。  Dr Skene�察�the most learned and accurate of all our  Highland historians�察�expresses his decided opinion that the charter is  forged and absolutely worthless as evidence in favour of the Fitzgerald  origin of the clan。  At pages 223´25 of his Highlanders of Scotland�察�he  says 

;The Mackenzies have long boasted of their descent from the great Norman family of Fitzgerald in Ireland�察�and in support of this origin they  produce a fragment of the Records of Icolmkill�察�and a charter by  Alexander III。 to Colin Fitzgerald�察�the supposed progenitor of the family�察 �of the lands of Kintail。 At first sight these documents might appear  conclusive�察�but�察�independently of the somewhat suspicious circumstance  that while these pages have been most freely and generally quoted�察�no one has ever seen the originals�察�and the fragment of the Icolmkill Record  merely says that among the actors in the battle of Largs�察�fought in 1263�察�was `Peregrinus et Hibernus nobilis ex familia Geraldinorum qui proximo anno Hibernia pulsus apud regni benigne acceptus hinc usque in curta  permansit et in praefacto proelio strenue pugnavit��' giving not a hint of his  having settled in the Highlands�察�or of his having become the progenitor of  any Scottish family whatever while as to the supposed charter of  Alexander III。�察�it is equally inconclusive�察�as it merely grants the lands of  Kintail to Colin Hiberno�察�the word `Hiberno' having at the time come into general use as denoting the Highlanders�察�in the same manner as the word  `Erse' is now frequently used to express their language�察�but inconclusive as it is�察�this charter�察─�he continues�察 �cannot be admitted at all�察�as it bears  the most palpable marks of having been a forgery of a later time�察�and one by no means happy in its execution。  How such a tradition of the origin of  the Mackenzies ever could have arisen�察�it is difficult to say but the fact of  their native origin and Gaelic descent is completely set at rest by the  Manuscript of 1450�察�which has already so often been the means of  detecting the falsehood of the foreign origins of other clans。;

Cosmo Innes�察�another high authority�察�editor of the Orgines Parachiales Scotia�察�the most valuable work ever published dealing with  the early history of Scotland�察�and especially of the Highlands�察�came to a similar conclusion�察�and expresses it even more strongly than Dr Skene。

At  pages 392´3�察�Vol。 II。�察�he says ;The lands of Kintail are said to have been  granted by Alexander III。 to Colin�察�an Irishman of the family of Fitzgerald�察 �for services done at the battle of Largs。 The charter is not extant�察�and its  genuineness has been doubted。; In a footnote�察�this learned antiquarian  gives the text of the document�察�in the same terms as those in which they  have been already quoted from another source�察�and which�察�he says�察�is  ;from a copy of the 17th century。;  ;If the charter be genuine�察─�he adds�察 �it is not of Alexander III。�察�or connected with the battle of Largs ��1263��。

Two of the witnesses�察�Andrew�察�Bishop of Moray�察�and Henry de Baliol�察�Chamberlain�察�would correspond with the 16th year of Alexander II。; He  further says that ;the writers of the history of the Mackenzies assert also  charters of David II。 ��1360�� and of Robert II。 ��1380�� to `Murdo filius  Kennethi de Kintail��' but without furnishing any description or means of  testing their authenticity。  No such charters are recorded。;

This is emphatic enough and to every unprejudiced mind  absolutely conclusive。  The sixteenth year of the reign of Alexander II。  was 1230�察�for he ascended the throne in 1214。  It necessarily follows that the charter�察�if signed at all�察�must have been signed thirty´three years before  the battle of Largs�察�and thirty´six years earlier than the actual date written  on the document itself。  If it had any existence before it appeared in the  Earl of Cromartie's manuscript of the seventeenth century�察�it must have  been written during the lives of the witnesses whose names attest it。

That  is�察�according to those who maintain that Colin Fitzgerald was the  progenitor of the Mackenzies�察�thirty´one years before that adventurer ever  crossed the Irish Channel�察�and probably several years before he was born�察�if he ever existed elsewhere than in the Earl of Cromartie's fertile  imagination。

But this is not all。  It has long been established beyond any possible doubt that the Earls of Ross were the superiors of the lands of  Kintail during the identical period in which the same lands are said to  have been held by Colin Fitzgerald and his descendants as direct vassals of  the Crown。 Ferchard Mac an t´Sagairt�察�Earl of Ross�察�received a grant of  the lands of Kintail from Alexander II。 for services rendered to that  monarch in 1222�察�and he is again on record as their possessor in 1234�察 �four years after the latest date on which the reputed charter to Colin  Fitzgerald�察�keeping in view the witnesses whose names appear on the face  of it�察�could possibly have been a genuine document。  Even the most  prominent of the clan historians who have so stoutly maintained the  Fitzgerald theory felt bound to admit that�察 �it cannot be disputed that the Earl of Ross was the Lord paramount under Alexander II。�察�by whom Farquhard Mac an t´Sagairt was recognised in the hereditary dignity of his  predecessors�察�and who�察�by another tradition�察─�Dr George Mackenzie says�察  �was a real progenitor of the noble family of Kintail。;  That the Earls of  Ross continued lords paramount long after the death of Colin Fitzgerald�察 �which event is said to have taken place in 1278�察�will be incontestibly  proved。

But meantime let us return to the Origines Parochiales Scotiae。 There we have it stated on authority which no one whose opinion is worth  anything will for a moment call in question。 The editor of that remarkable  work says�此  �In 1292 the Sheriffdom of Skye erected by King John Baliol�察�included the lands of the Earl of Ross in North Argyle�察�a district which  comprehended Kintail and several other large parishes in Ross ��Acts of  Parliament of Scotland�察�Vol。 1。 p。 917��。  Between 1306 and 1329 King  Robert Bruce confirmed to the Earl of Ross all his lands including North  Argyle ��Robertson's Index�察�p。 16�察�No。 7�察�Register of Moray�察�p。 342��。 in  1342�察�William�察�Earl of Ross�察�the son and heir of the deceased Hugh�察�Earl  of Ross�察�granted to Reginald�察�the son of Roderick ��Ranald Rorissoune or  MacRuaraidh�� of the Isles�察�the ten davochs ��or pennylands�� of Kintail in  North Argyle ��Robertson's Index�察�p。 48�察�No。 1�察�p。 99�察�p。 100�察�No。 1��。

The  grant was afterwards confirmed by King David II。 ��Robertson's Index��。   About the year 1346 Ranald was succeeded by his sister Amie�察�the wife of  John of Isla ��Gregory p。 27��。  Between the years 1362 and 1372�察�William�察 �Earl of Ross�察�exchanged with his brother Hugh of Ross�察�Lord of Phylorth�察 �and his heirs�察�his lands of all Argyle�察�with the Castle of Ellandonnan�察�for  Hugh's lands in Buchan ��Balnagown Charters��。  In 1463 the lands of  Kintail were held by Alexander Mackenzie ��Gregory�察�p�察�83���察─�when the  Mackenzies obtained the first authentic charter on record as direct vassals  from the Crown。

During the whole of this periodfor two hundred yearsthere is no trace of Colin Fitzgerald or any of his descendants as superiors of the  lands of Kintail in terms of Alexander III。's reputed charter of 1266�察�the  Mackenzies holding all that time from and as direct vassals of their  relatives�察�the Earls of Ross�察�who really held the position of Crown vassals  which�察�according to the upholders of the Fitzgerald theory�察�had that theory  been true�察�would have been held by Colin and his posterity。  But neither he  nor any of his reputed descendants appear once on record in that capacity during the whole of these two centuries。  On the contrary�察�it has now been  proved from unquestionable authentic sources th

卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��3�� 家��5��

低辛嬬浪散議