握握弌傍利 > 凪麿窮徨慕 > the evolution of modern medicine(�峇�匳勞議處延) >

及26嫗

the evolution of modern medicine(�峇�匳勞議處延)-及26嫗

弌傍�� the evolution of modern medicine(�峇�匳勞議處延) 忖方�� 耽匈3500忖

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��




capable of building the   Gothic cathedrals   may well   be called one of the 

great epochs in history�察�and the age that produced Dante is a golden one in 

literature。   Humanity   has   been   the   richer   for   St。   Francis�察  �and   Abelard�察�

Albertus   and      Aquinas     form   a   trio  not   easy   to  match�察   �in  their   special 

departments�察  �either   before   or   after。   But   in   science�察  �and   particularly   in 

medicine�察  �and   in   the   advance   of   an   outlook   upon   nature�察  �the   thirteenth 

century did not help man very much。 Roger Bacon was ;a voice crying in 

the   wilderness�察─  �and   not   one   of   the   men   I   have   picked   out   as   specially 

typical of the period instituted any new departure either in practice or in 

science。   They   were   servile   followers�察  �when   not   of   the   Greeks�察  �of   the 

Arabians。 This is attested by the barrenness of the century and a half that 

followed。 One would have thought that the stimulus given by Mundinus to 

the study of anatomy would have borne fruit�察�but little was done in science 

during   the     two   and   a   half  centuries    that   followed    the   delivery   of   his 

lectures and still less in the art。 While William of Wykeham was building 

Winchester Cathedral and Chaucer was writing the Canterbury Tales�察�John 

of    Gaddesden       in  practice    was   blindly    following     blind    leaders    whose 

authority no one dared question。 

     The truth is�察�from the modern standpoint the thirteenth was not the true 

dawn   brightening   more   and   more   unto   the   perfect   day�察  �but   a   glorious 

aurora which flickered down again into the arctic night of mediaevalism。 

     To sum upin medicine the Middle Ages represent a restatement from 

century to century of the facts and theories of the Greeks modified here 

and there by Arabian practice。 There was�察�in Francis Bacon's phrase�察�much 

iteration�察    �small     addition。     The    schools      bowed      in   humble�察     �slavish 

submission   to   Galen   and   Hippocrates�察  �taking   everything   from   them   but 

their spirit and there was no advance in our knowledge of the structure or 

function of the body。 The Arabians lit a brilliant torch from Grecian lamps 

and    from    the   eighth    to  the   eleventh    centuries    the   profession     reached 

among them  a   position   of   dignity  and   importance   to   which   it is   hard   to 

find a parallel in history。 



                                                 101 


´ Page 102´

                       THE EVOLUTION OF MODERN MEDICINE 



                             CHAPTER IV 



        THE RENAISSANCE AND THE RISE OF ANATOMY AND 

                                  PHYSIOLOGY 

     THE ;reconquest of the classic world of thought was by far the most 

important achievement of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries。 It absorbed 

nearly the whole mental energy of   the Italians。。。。 The revelation of   what 

men were and what they wrought under the influence of other faiths and 

other impulses�察�in distant ages with a different ideal for their aim�察�not only 

widened the narrow horizon of the Middle Ages�察�but it also restored self´ 

confidence to the reason of humanity。;��1�А�

     ��1�А�J。 A。 Symonds�此�The Renaissance in Italy�察�the Revival of Learning�察�

1877�察�p。 52。 

       Everywhere throughout the Middle Ages learning was the handmaid 

of theology。 Even Roger Bacon with his strong appeal for a new method 

accepted the dominant mediaeval convictionthat all the sciences did but 

minister to their queen�察�Theology。 A new spirit entered man's heart as he 

came to look upon learning as a guide to the conduct of life。 A revolution 

was slowly effected in the intellectual world。 It is a mistake to think of the 

Renaissance   as   a   brief   period of   sudden   fruitfulness   in   the   North   Italian 

cities。 So far as science is concerned�察�the thirteenth century was an aurora 

followed by a long period of darkness�察�but the fifteenth was a true dawn 

that brightened more and more unto the perfect day。 Always a reflex of its 

period�察   �medicine    joined   heartily   though    slowly    in  the  revolt  against 

mediaevalism。 How slowly I did not appreciate until recently。 Studying the 

earliest printed medical works to catch the point of view of the men who 

were in the   thick of the   movement   up to 1480 which   may  be   taken   to 

include   the   first   quarter   of   a   century   of   printing   one   gets   a   startling 

record。 The mediaeval mind still dominates�此�of the sixty´seven authors of 

one hundred and eighty´two editions of early medical books�察�twenty´three 

were   men   of   the   thirteenth   and   fourteenth   centuries�察  �thirty   men   of   the 

fifteenth   century�察  �eight   wrote   in   Arabic�察  �several   were   of   the   School   of 

Salernum�察�and only six were of classical antiquity�察�viz。�察�Pliny ��first 1469���察�

Hippocrates   ��1473��   ��Hain   ��*��7247�В察  �Galen   ��1475��   ��Hain   7237�В察�Aristotle 



                                             102 


´ Page 103´

                        THE EVOLUTION OF MODERN MEDICINE 



��1476���察�Celsus ��1478���察�and Dioscorides ��1478��。��**�А�

     ��*�А�This asterisk is used by Hain to indicate that he had seen a copy。 

Ed。 

     ��**�А�Data added to a manuscript taken from the author's summary on 

;Printed   Medical   Books   to   1480;   in   Transactions   of   the   Bibliographical 

Society�察�London�察�1916�察�XIII�察�5´8�察�revised from its ;News´Sheet; ��February�察�

1914��。 ;Of neither Hippocrates nor Galen is there an early edition�察�but in 

1473   at   Pavia   appeared   an   exposition   of   the Aphorisms   of   Hippoerates�察�

and in 1475 at Padua an edition of the Tegni or Notes of Galen。; Ibid。�察�p。 6。 

Osler's   unfinished   Illustrated   Monograph   on   this   subject   is   now   being 

printed for the Society of which he was President。Ed。 

       The medical profession gradually caught the new spirit。 It has been 

well said that Greece arose from the dead with the New Testament in the 

one hand and Aristotle in the other。 There was awakened a perfect passion 

for the old Greek writers�察�and with it a study of the original sources�察�which 

had   now   become   available   in   many   manuscripts。   Gradually   Hippocrates 

and Galen came to their own again。 Almost every professor of medicine 

became   a   student of   the   MSS。   of Aristotle   and   of   the   Greek   physicians�察�

and before 1530 the presses had poured out a stream of editions。 A wave 

of enthusiasm swept over the profession�察�and the best energies of its best 

minds were devoted to a study of the Fathers。 Galen became the idol of the 

schools。   A   strong   revulsion   of   feeling   arose   against   the   Arabians�察  �and 

Avicenna�察�the Prince�察�who had been clothed with an authority only a little 

less    than    divine�察  �became      anathema。      Under     the   leadership     of   the 

Montpellier School�察�the Arabians made a strong fight�察�but it was a losing 

battle all along the line。 This group of medical humanistsmen who were 

devoted   to   the   study   of   the   old   humanities�察  �as   Latin   and   Greek   were 

called has had a great and beneficial influence upon the profession。 They 

were for the most part cultivated gentlemen with a triple interestliterature�察�

medicine and natural history。 How important is the part they played may 

be gathered from a glance at the ;Lives; given by Bayle in his ;Biographic 

Medicale; ��Paris�察�1855�� between the years 1500 and 1575。 More than one 

half of them had translated or edited works of Hippocrates or Galen�察�many 

of them had made important contributions to general literature�察�and a large 



                                              103 


´ Page 104´

                        THE EVOLUTION OF MODERN MEDICINE 



proportion      of  them    were    naturalists�此  �Leonicenus�察     �Linacre�察   �Champier�察�

Fernel�察   �Fracastorius�察    �Gonthier�察   �Caius�察  �J。  Sylvius�察  �Brasavola�察    �Fuchsius�察�

Matthiolus�察  �Conrad   Gesner�察  �to   mention   only   those   I   know   best�察  �form   a 

great   group。   Linacre   edited   Greek   works   for Aldus�察  �translated   works   of 

Galen�察  �taught   Greek   at   Oxford�察  �wrote   Latin   grammars   and   founded   the 

Royal College of Physicians。��*�А�Caius was a keen Greek scholar�察�an ardent 

student of natural history�察�and his name is enshrined as co´founder of one 

of the most important of the Cambridge colleges。 Gonthier�察�Fernel�察�Fuchs 

and Mattioli were great scholars and greater physicians。 Champier�察�one of 

the most remarkable   of the group�察 �was the  founder of the  Hotel Dieu   at 

Lyons�察  �and   author   of   books   of   a   characteristic   Renaissance   type   and   of 

singular bibliographical interest。 In many ways greatest of all was Conrad 

Gesner�察�whose mors inopinata at forty´nine�察�bravely fighting the plague�察�is 

so   touchingly   and   tenderly   mourned   by   his   friend   Caius。��2�А  �Physician�察�

botanist�察    �mineralogist�察     �geologist�察   �chemist�察    �the    first   great   modern 

bibliographer�察�he is the very embodiment of the spirit of the age。��2a�А�On 

the flyleaf of my copy of the ;Bibliotheca Universalis; ��1545���察�is written a 

fine tribute to his memory。 I do not know by whom it is�察�but I do know 

from my reading that it is true�此�

     ��*�А  �Cf。   Osler�此  �Thomas   Linacre�察  �Cambridge   University   Press�察  �1908。 

Ed。 

     ��2�А�Joannis Caii Britanni de libris suis�察�etc。�察�1570。 

     ��2a�А�See J。 C。 Bay�此�Papers Bibliog。 Soc。 of America�察�1916�察�X�察�No。 2�察�

53´86。 

       ;Conrad Gesner�察�who kept open house there for all learned men who 

came     into   his  neighborhood。      Gesner    was    not  only   the   best  naturalist 

among the scholars of his day�察�but of all men of that century he was the 

pattern man of letters。 He was faultless in private life�察�assiduous in study�察�

diligent in maintaining correspondence and good´will with learned men in 

all countries�察�hospitablethough his means were small to every scholar 

that came into Zurich。 Prompt to serve all�察�he was an editor of other men's 

volumes�察�a writer of prefaces for friends�察�a suggestor to young writers of 

books on which they might engage themselves�察�and a great helper to them 

in the progress of their work。 But still�察�while finding time for services to 



                                               104 


´ Page 105´

                        THE EVOLUTION OF MODERN MEDICINE 



other men�察�he could produce as much out of his own study as though he 

had no part in the life beyond its walls。; 

     A    large   majority     of   these   early   naturalists    and    botanists    were 

physicians。��3�А�The Greek art of observation was revived in a study of the 

scientific    writings    of  Aristotle�察  �Theophrastus       and   Dioscorides     and    in 

med

卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��2�� 家��2��

低辛嬬浪散議