握握弌傍利 > 凪麿窮徨慕 > the evolution of modern medicine(�峇�匳勞議處延) >

及21嫗

the evolution of modern medicine(�峇�匳勞議處延)-及21嫗

弌傍�� the evolution of modern medicine(�峇�匳勞議處延) 忖方�� 耽匈3500忖

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��




     ��13�А�Neuburger�此�History of Medicine�察�Vol。 I�察�pp。 368´369。 

       Innumerable manuscripts of it exist�此�of one of the most beautiful�察�a 

Hebrew version ��Bologna Library���察�I give an illustration。 A Latin version 

was   printed   in   1472   and   there   are   many   later   editions�察  �the   last   in   1663。 

Avicenna      was    not   only   a  successful    writer�察  �but   the  prototype     of  the 

successful      physician     who    was    at  the   same    time   statesman�察    �teacher�察�

philosopher and literary man。 Rumor has it that he became dissipated�察�and 

a   contemporary   saying   was   that   all   his   philosophy   could   not   make   him 

moral�察�nor all his physic   teach him to preserve   his health。 He enjoyed   a 

great reputation as a poet。 I reproduce a page of a manuscript of one of his 

poems�察�which we have in the Bodleian Library。 Prof。 A。V。W。 Jackson says 

that some of his verse is peculiarly Khayyamesque�察�though he antedated 

Omar   by   a   century。   That   ;large   Infidel;   might   well   have   written   such   a 

stanza as 

     From Earth's dark centre unto Saturn's Gate I've solved all problems of 

this world's Estate�察�From every snare of Plot and Guile set free�察�Each bond 

resolved�察�saving alone Death's Fate。 

     His hymn to the Deity might have been written by Plato and rivals the 

famous      one   of   Cleanthes。��14�А    �A   casual    reader   gets   a  very   favorable 

impression of Avicenna。 The story of his dominion over the schools in the 

Middle Ages is one of the most striking in our history。 Perhaps we feel that 

Leclerc      exaggerates      when      he   says�此    �Avicenna       is  an    intellectual 

phenomenon。 Never perhaps has an example been seen of so precocious�察�

quick and wide an intellect extending and asserting itself with so strange 

and   indefatigable   an   activity。;   The   touch   of   the   man   never   reached   me 

until I read some of his mystical and philosophical writings translated by 



                                                81 


´ Page 82´

                        THE EVOLUTION OF MODERN MEDICINE 



Mehren。��15�А�It is Plato over   again。 The beautiful  allegory in   which   men 

are likened to birds snared and caged until set free by the Angel of Death 

might be met with   anywhere in the immortal   Dialogues。 The tractate   on 

Love   is   a   commentary   on   the   Symposium�察  �and   the   essay   on   Destiny   is 

Greek in spirit without a trace of Oriental fatalism�察�as you may judge from 

the concluding sentence�察�which I leave you as his special message�此 �Take 

heed to the limits of your capacity and you will arrive at a knowledge of 

the truth� �How true is the saying��Work ever and to each will come that 

measure of success for which Nature has designed him。; Avicenna died in 

his fifty´eighth year。 When he saw that physic was of no avail�察�resigning 

himself to the inevitable�察�he sold his goods�察�distributed the money to the 

poor�察�read the Koran through once every three days�察�and died in the holy 

month   of   Ramadan。   His   tomb   at   Hamadan�察  �the   ancient   Ecbatana�察  �still 

exists�察�a simple brickwork building�察�rectangular in shape�察�and surrounded 

by an unpretentious court。 It was restored in 1877�察�but is again in need of 

repair。    The   illustration   here   shown     is  from   a  photograph      sent  by   Dr。 

Neligan     of   Teheran。    Though     dead�察  �the   great   Persian    has  still  a  large 

practice�察�as his tomb is much visited by pilgrims�察�among whom cures are 

said to be not uncommon。 

     ��14�А �L'hymne d'Avicenne; in�此�L'Elegie du Tograi�察�etc。�察�par P。 Vattier�察�

Paris�察�1660。 

     ��15�А  �Traites   mystiques   d'Abou Ali   al´Hosain   b。 Abdallah   b。   Sina   ou 

d'Avicenne   par   M。 A。   F。   Mehren�察  �Leyden�察  �E。   J。   Brill�察  �Fasc。   I´IV�察  �1889´ 

1899。 

       The Western Caliphate produced physicians and philosophers almost 

as   brilliant   as   those   of   the   East。   Remarkable   schools   of   medicine   were 

founded      at   Seville�察  �Toledo     and   Cordova。     The    most    famous     of   the 

professors   were   Averroes�察  �Albucasis   and   Avenzoar。   Albucasis   was   ;the 

Arabian restorer of surgery。; Averroes�察�called in the Middle Ages ;the Soul 

of    Aristotle;    or   ;the   Commentator�察─       �is  better   known     today    among 

philosophers than physicians。 On the revival of Moslem orthodoxy he fell 

upon     evil  days�察   �was   persecuted     as   a  free´thinker�察   �and   the   saying    is 

attributed to him;Sit anima mea cum philosophic。; 

     Arabian   medicine   had   certain   very   definite   characteristics�此  �the   basis 



                                                82 


´ Page 83´

                        THE EVOLUTION OF MODERN MEDICINE 



was   Greek�察  �derived   from   translations   of   the   works   of   Hippocrates   and 

Galen。     No    contributions     were    made     to  anatomy�察    �as  dissections     were 

prohibited�察  �nor   to   physiology�察  �and   the   pathology   was   practically   that   of 

Galen。 Certain   new and important diseases were described�察�a number   of 

new     and   active   remedies     were    introduced�察   �chiefly   from   the    vegetable 

kingdom。 The Arabian hospitals were well organized and were deservedly 

famous。 No such hospital exists today in Cairo as that which was built by 

al´Mansur   Gilafun   in   1283。 The   description   of   it   by   Makrizi�察 �quoted   by 

Neuburger�撮�16�А       �reads   like   that  of  a  twentieth     century    institution   with 

hospital units。 

     ��16�А   �I   have   founded     this  institution    for  my   equals    and   for  those 

beneath me�察�it is intended for rulers and subjects�察�for soldiers and for the 

emir�察  �for   great   and   small�察  �freemen   and   slaves�察  �men   and   women。;   ;He 

ordered      medicaments�察      �physicians     and    everything     else   that   could    be 

required   by   anyone   in   any   form   of   sickness�察  �placed   male   and   female 

attendants at the  disposal of   the patients�察 �determined   their  pay�察 �provided 

beds for patients and supplied them with every kind of covering that could 

be required in any complaint。 Every class of patient was accorded separate 

accommodation�此�the four halls of the hospital were set apart for those with 

fever   and   similar   complaints�察  �one   part   of   the   building   was   reserved   for 

eye´patients�察�one for the wounded�察�one for those suffering from diarrhoea�察�

one for women�察�a room for convalescents was divided into two parts�察�one 

for men and one for women。 Water was laid on to all these departments。 

One room was set apart for cooking food�察�preparing medicine and cooking 

syrups�察�another for the compounding of confections�察�balsams�察�eye´salves�察�

etc。 The head´physician had an apartment to himself wherein he delivered 

medical lectures。 The number of patients was unlimited�察�every sick or poor 

person   who   came   found   admittance�察  �nor   was   the   duration          of   his   stay 

restricted�察�and even those who were sick at home were supplied with every 

necessity。;Makrizi。 

     ;In   later   times   this   hospital   was   much   extended   and   improved。   The 

nursing   was   admirable   and   no   stint   was   made   of   drugs   and   appliances�察�

each patient was provided with means upon leaving so that he should not 

require   immediately   to   undertake   heavy   work。;   Neuburger�此  �History   of 



                                                83 


´ Page 84´

                        THE EVOLUTION OF MODERN MEDICINE 



Medicine�察�Vol。 1�察�p。 378。 

       It was in   the domain of   chemistry that the Arabs made the greatest 

advances。 You may remember that�察�in Egypt�察�chemistry had already made 

considerable strides�察�and I alluded to Prof。 Elliot Smith's view that one of 

the great leaps in civilization was the discovery in the Nile Valley of the 

metallurgy      of   copper。    In  the   brilliant   period    of  the   Ptolemies�察    �both 

chemistry  and   pharmacology   were   studied�察  �and   it   seems   not   improbable 

that�察  �when   the   Arabs   took   Alexandria   in   the   year   640�察  �there   were   still 

many workers in these subjects。 

     The    most    famous     of   those   early   Arabic    writers    is  the  somewhat 

mythical   Geber�察  �who   lived   in   the   first   half   of   the   eighth   century�察  �and 

whose      writings   had    an  extraordinary   influence       throughout     the   Middle 

Ages。   The   whole   story   of   Geber   is   discussed   by   Berthelot   in   his   ;La 

chimie au moyen age; ��Paris�察�1896��。 The transmission of Arabian science 

to   the   Occident   began   with   the   Crusades�察  �though   earlier   a   filtering   of 

important knowledge in mathematics and astronomy had reached Southern 

and   Middle   Europe through   Spain。 Among   the translators several   names 

stand out prominently。 Gerbert�察�who became later Pope Sylvester II�察�is said 

to have given us our present Arabic figures。 You may read the story of his 

remarkable life in Taylor�撮�17�А�who says he was ;the first mind of his time�察�

its greatest teacher�察�its most eager learner�察�and most universal scholar。; But 

he does not seem to have done much directly for medicine。 

     ��17�А�The Mediaeval Mind�察�Vol。 I�察�p。 280。 

       The Graeco´Arabic learning passed into Europe through two sources。 

As   I   have   already   mentioned�察  �Constantinus   Africanus�察  �a   North   African 

Christian     monk�察    �widely    travelled    and    learned    in  languages�察    �came    to 

Salernum and translated many works from Arabic into Latin�察�particularly 

those of Hippocrates and Galen。 The ;Pantegni; of the latter became one 

of   the   most   popular  text´books   of   the Middle Ages。 A  long   list   of   other 

works     which     he   translated   is  given    by   Steinschneider。��17a�А      �It  is  not 

unlikely   that   Arabic   medicine   had   already   found   its   way   to   Salernum 

before the time of Constantine�察�but the influence of his translations upon 

the later Middle Ages was very great。 

     ��17a�А�Steinschneider�此�Virchow's Arch。�察�Berl。�察�1867�察�xxxvii�察�351。 



                                                84 


´ Page 85´

                        THE EVOLUTION OF MODERN MEDICINE 



       The second was a more important source through the Latin translators 

in Spain�察�particularly in Toledo�察�where�察�from the middle of the twelfth till 

the   middle   of   the   thirteenth   century�察  �an   extraordinary   number   of Arabic 

works in philosophy�察�mathematics and astronomy were translated。 Among 

the translators�察�Gerard of Cremona is prominent�察�and has been called the 

;Father  of Translators。;   He   was   one   of   the   brightest   intelligences   of   the 

Middle Ages�察�and di

卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��2�� 家��2��

低辛嬬浪散議