握握弌傍利 > 凪麿窮徨慕 > orthodoxy >

及7嫗

orthodoxy-及7嫗

弌傍�� orthodoxy 忖方�� 耽匈3500忖

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��






an innocent scientific description of how certain earthly things



came about�察�or�察�if it is anything more than this�察�it is an attack



upon thought itself。  If evolution destroys anything�察�it does not



destroy religion but rationalism。  If evolution simply means that



a positive thing called an ape turned very slowly into a positive



thing called a man�察�then it is stingless for the most orthodox��



for a personal God might just as well do things slowly as quickly��



especially if�察�like the Christian God�察�he were outside time。 



But if it means anything more�察�it means that there is no such



thing as an ape to change�察�and no such thing as a man for him



to change into。  It means that there is no such thing as a thing。 



At best�察�there is only one thing�察�and that is a flux of everything



and anything。  This is an attack not upon the faith�察�but upon



the mind�察�you cannot think if there are no things to think about。 



You cannot think if you are not separate from the subject of thought。 



Descartes said�察 �I think�察�therefore I am。;  The philosophic evolutionist



reverses and negatives the epigram。  He says�察 �I am not�察�therefore I



cannot think。;







     Then there is the opposite attack on thought�此 �that urged by



Mr。 H。G。Wells when he insists that every separate thing is ;unique�察�



and there are no categories at all。  This also is merely destructive。 



Thinking means connecting things�察�and stops if they cannot be connected。 



It need hardly be said that this scepticism forbidding thought



necessarily forbids speech�察�a man cannot open his mouth without



contradicting it。  Thus when Mr。 Wells says ��as he did somewhere����



;All chairs are quite different�察─�he utters not merely a misstatement��



but a contradiction in terms。  If all chairs were quite different��



you could not call them ;all chairs。;







     Akin to these is the false theory of progress�察�which maintains



that we alter the test instead of trying to pass the test。 



We often hear it said�察�for instance�察 �What is right in one age



is wrong in another。;  This is quite reasonable�察�if it means that



there is a fixed aim�察�and that certain methods attain at certain



times and not at other times。  If women�察�say�察�desire to be elegant��



it may be that they are improved at one time by growing fatter and



at another time by growing thinner。  But you cannot say that they



are improved by ceasing to wish to be elegant and beginning to wish



to be oblong。  If the standard changes�察�how can there be improvement��



which implies a standard�拭 �Nietzsche started a nonsensical idea that



men had once sought as good what we now call evil�察�if it were so��



we could not talk of surpassing or even falling short of them。 



How can you overtake Jones if you walk in the other direction�拭�



You cannot discuss whether one people has succeeded more in being



miserable than another succeeded in being happy。  It would be



like discussing whether Milton was more puritanical than a pig



is fat。







     It is true that a man ��a silly man�� might make change itself his



object or ideal。  But as an ideal�察�change itself becomes unchangeable。 



If the change´worshipper wishes to estimate his own progress�察�he must



be sternly loyal to the ideal of change�察�he must not begin to flirt



gaily with the ideal of monotony。  Progress itself cannot progress。 



It is worth remark�察�in passing�察�that when Tennyson�察�in a wild and rather



weak manner�察�welcomed the idea of infinite alteration in society��



he instinctively took a metaphor which suggests an imprisoned tedium。 



He wrote







     ;Let the great world spin for ever down the ringing grooves



of change。;







He thought of change itself as an unchangeable groove�察�and so it is。 



Change is about the narrowest and hardest groove that a man can



get into。







     The main point here�察�however�察�is that this idea of a fundamental



alteration in the standard is one of the things that make thought



about the past or future simply impossible。  The theory of a



complete change of standards in human history does not merely



deprive us of the pleasure of honouring our fathers�察�it deprives



us even of the more modern and aristocratic pleasure of despising them。







     This bald summary of the thought´destroying forces of our



time would not be complete without some reference to pragmatism��



for though I have here used and should everywhere defend the



pragmatist method as a preliminary guide to truth�察�there is an extreme



application of it which involves the absence of all truth whatever。 



My meaning can be put shortly thus。  I agree with the pragmatists



that apparent objective truth is not the whole matter�察�that there



is an authoritative need to believe the things that are necessary



to the human mind。  But I say that one of those necessities



precisely is a belief in objective truth。  The pragmatist tells



a man to think what he must think and never mind the Absolute。 



But precisely one of the things that he must think is the Absolute。 



This philosophy�察�indeed�察�is a kind of verbal paradox。  Pragmatism is



a matter of human needs�察�and one of the first of human needs



is to be something more than a pragmatist。  Extreme pragmatism



is just as inhuman as the determinism it so powerfully attacks。 



The determinist ��who�察�to do him justice�察�does not pretend to be



a human being�� makes nonsense of the human sense of actual choice。 



The pragmatist�察�who professes to be specially human�察�makes nonsense



of the human sense of actual fact。







     To sum up our contention so far�察�we may say that the most



characteristic current philosophies have not only a touch of mania��



but a touch of suicidal mania。  The mere questioner has knocked



his head against the limits of human thought�察�and cracked it。 



This is what makes so futile the warnings of the orthodox and the



boasts of the advanced about the dangerous boyhood of free thought。 



What we are looking at is not the boyhood of free thought�察�it is



the old age and ultimate dissolution of free thought。  It is vain



for bishops and pious bigwigs to discuss what dreadful things will



happen if wild scepticism runs its course。  It has run its course。 



It is vain for eloquent atheists to talk of the great truths that



will be revealed if once we see free thought begin。  We have seen



it end。  It has no more questions to ask�察�it has questioned itself。 



You cannot call up any wilder vision than a city in which men



ask themselves if they have any selves。  You cannot fancy a more



sceptical world than that in which men doubt if there is a world。 



It might certainly have reached its bankruptcy more quickly



and cleanly if it had not been feebly hampered by the application



of indefensible laws of blasphemy or by the absurd pretence



that modern England is Christian。  But it would have reached the



bankruptcy anyhow。  Militant atheists are still unjustly persecuted��



but rather because they are an old minority than because they



are a new one。  Free thought has exhausted its own freedom。 



It is weary of its own success。  If any eager freethinker now hails



philosophic freedom as the dawn�察�he is only like the man in Mark



Twain who came out wrapped in blankets to see the sun rise and was



just in time to see it set。  If any frightened curate still says



that it will be awful if the darkness of free thought should spread��



we can only answer him in the high and powerful words of Mr。 Belloc��



;Do not�察�I beseech you�察�be troubled about the increase of forces



already in dissolution。  You have mistaken the hour of the night�此�



it is already morning。;  We have no more questions left to ask。 



We have looked for questions in the darkest corners and on the



wildest peaks。  We have found all the questions that can be found。 



It is time we gave up looking for questions and began looking



for answers。







     But one more word must be added。  At the beginning of this



preliminary negative sketch I said that our mental ruin has



been wrought by wild reason�察�not by wild imagination。  A man



does not go mad because he makes a statue a mile high�察�but he



may go mad by thinking it out in square inches。  Now�察�one school



of thinkers has seen this and jumped at it as a way of renewing



the pagan health of the world。  They see that reason destroys��



but Will�察�they say�察�creates。  The ultimate authority�察�they say��



is in will�察�not in reason。  The supreme point is not why



a man demands a thing�察�but the fact that he does demand it。 



I have no space to trace or expound this philosophy of Will。 



It came�察�I suppose�察�through Nietzsche�察�who preached something



that is called egoism。  That�察�indeed�察�was simpleminded enough��



for Nietzsche denied egoism simply by preaching it。  To preach



anything is to give it away。  First�察�the egoist calls life a war



without mercy�察�and then he takes the greatest possible trouble to



drill his enemies in war。  To preach egoism is to practise altruism。 



But however it began�察�the view is common enough in current literature。 



The main defence of these thinkers is that they are not thinkers��



they are makers。  They say that choice is itself the divine thing。 



Thus Mr。 Bernard Shaw has attacked the old idea that men's acts



are to be judged by the standard of the desire of happiness。 



He says that a man does not act for his happiness�察�but from his will。 



He does not say�察 �Jam will make me happy�察─�but ;I want jam。; 



And in all this others follow him with yet greater enthusiasm。 



Mr。 John Davidson�察�a remarkable poet�察�is so passionately excited



about it that he is obliged to write prose。  He publishes a short



play with several long prefaces。  This is natural enough in Mr。 Shaw��



for all his plays are prefaces�此 �Mr。 Shaw is ��I suspect�� the only man



on earth who has never written any poetry。  But that Mr。 Davidson ��who



can write excellent poetry�� should write instead laborious metaphysics



in defence of this doctrine of will�察�does show that the doctrine



of will has taken hold of men。  Even Mr。 H。G。Wells has half spoken



in its language�察�saying that one should test acts not like a thinker��



but like an artist�察�saying�察 �I FEEL this curve is right�察─�or ;that



line SHALL go thus。;  They are all excited�察�and well they may be。 



For by this doctrine of the divine authority of will�察�they think they



can break out of the doomed fortress of rationalism。  They think they



c

卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��7�� 家��5��

低辛嬬浪散議