the comparison of tiberius and caius gracchus-及1嫗
梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
THE COMPARISON OF TIBERIUS AND CAIUS GRACCHUS
WITH AGIS AND CLEOMENES
by Plutarch
translated by John Dryden
HAVING given an account severally of these persons�察�it remains
only that we should take a view of them in comparison with one
another。
As for the Gracchi�察�the greatest detractors and their worst
enemies could not but allow that they had a genius to virtue beyond
all other Romans�察�which was improved also by a generous education。
Agis and Cleomenes may be supposed to have had stronger natural gifts��
since�察�though they wanted all the advantages of good education�察�and
were bred up in those very customs�察�manners�察�and habits of living
which had for a long time corrupted others�察�yet they were public
examples of temperance and frugality。 Besides�察�the Gracchi��
happening to live when Rome had her greatest repute for honour and
virtuous actions�察�might justly have been ashamed�察�if they had not also
left to the next generation the noble inheritance of the virtues of
their ancestors。 Whereas the other two had parents of different
morals�察�and though they found their country in a sinking condition��
and debauched�察�yet that did not quench their forward zeal to what
was just and honourable。
The integrity of the two Romans�察�and their superiority to money�察�was
chiefly remarkable in this�此�that in office and the administration of
public affairs�察�they kept themselves from the imputation of unjust
gain�察�whereas Agis might justly be offended if he had only that mean
commendation given him�察�that he took nothing wrongfully from any
man�察�seeing he distributed his own fortunes which�察�in ready money
only�察�amounted to the value of six hundred talents�察�amongst his
fellow´citizens。 Extortion would have appeared a crime of a strange
nature to him�察�who esteemed it a piece of covetousness to possess��
though never so justly gotten�察�greater riches than his neighbours。
Their political actions�察�also�察�and the state revolutions they
attempted�察�were very different in magnitude。 The chief things in
general that the two Romans commonly aimed at�察�were the settlement
of cities and mending of highways�察�and�察�in particular�察�the boldest
design which Tiberius is famed for�察�was the recovery of the public
lands�察�and Caius gained his greatest reputation by the addition�察�for
the exercise of judiciary powers�察�of three hundred of the order of
knights to the same number of senators。 Whereas the alteration which
Agis and Cleomenes made was in a quite different kind。 They did not
set about removing partial evils and curing petty incidents of
disease�察�which would have been ��as Plato says�� like cutting off one of
the Hydra's heads�察�the very means to increase the number�察�but they
instituted a thorough reformation�察�such as would free the country from
all its grievances�察�or rather�察�to speak more truly�察�they reversed that
former change which had been the cause of all their calamities�察�and so
restored their city to its ancient state。
However�察�this must be confessed in the behalf of the Gracchi�察�that
their undertakings were always opposed by men of the greatest
influence。 On the other side�察�those things which were first
attempted by Agis�察�and afterwards consummated by Cleomenes�察�were
supported by the great and glorious precedent of those ancient laws
concerning frugality and levelling which they had themselves
received upon the authority of Lycurgus�察�and he had instituted on that
of Apollo。 It is also further observable�察�that from the actions of the
Gracchi�察�Rome received no additions to her former greatness��
whereas�察�under the conduct of Cleomenes�察�Greece presently saw Sparta
exert her sovereign power over all Peloponnesus�察�and contest the
supreme command with the most powerful princes of the time�察�success in
which would have freed Greece from Illyrian and Gaulish violence��
and placed her once again under the orderly rule of the sons of
Hercules。
From the circumstances of their deaths�察�also�察�we may infer some
difference in the quality of their courage。 The Gracchi�察�fighting with
their fellow´citizens�察�were both slain as they endeavoured to make��
their escape�察�Agis willingly submitted to his fate�察�rather than any
citizen should be in danger of his life。 Cleomenes�察�being shamefully
and unjustly treated�察�made an effort toward revenge�察�but failing of
that�察�generously fell by his own hand。
On the other side it must be said�察�that Agis never did a great
action worthy a commander�察�being prevented by an untimely death。 And
as for those heroic actions of Cleomenes�察�we may justly compare with
them that of Tiberius�察�when he was the first who attempted to scale
the walls of Carthage�察�which was no mean exploit。 We may add the peace
which he concluded with the Numantines�察�by which he saved the lives of
twenty thousand Romans�察�who otherwise had certainly been cut off。
And Caius�察�not only at home�察�but in war in Sardinia�察�displayed
distinguished courage。 So that their early actions were no small
argument that afterwards they might have rivalled the best of the
Roman commanders�察�if they had not died so young。
In civil life�察�Agis showed a lack of determination�察�he let himself
be baffled by the craft of Agesilaus�察�disappointed the expectations of
the citizens as to the division of the lands�察�and generally left all
the designs�察�which he had deliberately formed and publicly
announced�察�unperformed and unfulfilled through a young man's want of
resolution。 Cleomenes�察�on the other hand�察�proceeded to effect the
revolution with only too much boldness and violence�察�and unjustly slew
the Ephors whom he might�察�by superiority in arms�察�have gained over
to his party�察�or else might easily have banished�察�as he did several
others of the city。 For to use the knife�察�unless in the extremest
necessity�察�is neither good surgery nor wise policy�察�but in both
cases mere unskillfulness�察�and in the latter�察�unjust as well as
unfeeling。 Of the Gracchi�察�neither the one nor the other was the first
to shed the blood of his fellow´citizens�察�and Caius is reported to
have avoided all manner of resistance�察�even when his life was aimed
at�察�showing himself always valiant against a foreign enemy�察�but wholly
inactive in a sedition。 This was the reason that he went from his
own house unarmed�察�and withdrew when the battle began�察�and in all
respects showed himself anxious rather not to do any harm to others��
than not to suffer any himself。 Even the very flight of the Gracchi
must not be looked upon as an argument of their mean spirit�察�but an
honourable retreat from endangering of others。 For if they had stayed��
they must either have yielded to those who assailed them�察�or else have
fought them in their own defence。
The greatest crime that can be laid to Tiberius's charge was the
deposing of his fellow tribune�察�and seeking afterwards a second
tribuneship for himself。 As for the death of Antyllius�察�it is
falsely and unjustly attributed to Caius�察�for he was slain unknown
to him�察�and much to his grief。 On the contrary�察�Cleomenes ��not to
mention the murder of the Ephors�� set all the slaves at liberty�察�and
governed by himself alone in reality�察�having a partner only for
show�察�having made choice of his brother Euclidas�察�who was one of the
same family。 He prevailed upon Archidamus�察�who was the right heir to
the kingdom of the other line�察�to venture to return home from Messene��
but after his being slain�察�by not doing anything to revenge his death��
confirmed the suspicion that he was privy to it himself。 Lycurgus��
whose example he professed to imitate�察�after he had voluntarily
settled his kingdom upon Charillus�察�his brother's son�察�fearing lest��
if the youth should chance to die by accident�察�he might be suspected
for it�察�travelled a long time�察�and would not return again to Sparta
until Charillus had a son�察�and an heir to his kingdom。 But we have
indeed no other Grecian who is worthy to be compared with Lycurgus��
and it is clear enough that in the public measures of Cleomenes
various acts of considerable audacity and lawlessness may be found。
Those�察�therefore�察�who incline to blame their characters may observe��
that the two Grecians were disturbers even from their youth�察�lovers of
contest�察�and aspirants to despotic power�察�that Tiberius and Caius by
nature had an excessive desire after glory and honours。 Beyond this��
their enemies could find nothing to bring against them�察�but as soon as
the contention began with their adversaries�察�their heat and passions
would so far prevail beyond their natural temper�察�that by them�察�as
by ill winds�察�they were driven afterwards to all their rash
undertakings。 What could be more just and honourable than their
first design�察�had not the power and the faction of the rich�察�by
endeavouring to abrogate that law�察�engaged them both in those fatal
quarrels�察�the one�察�for his own preservation�察�the other�察�to revenge his
brother's death�察�who was murdered without any law or justice��
From the account�察�therefore�察�which has been given�察�you yourself
may perceive the difference�察�which if it were to be pronounced of
every one singly�察�I should affirm Tiberius to have excelled them all
in virtue�察�that young Agis had been guilty of the fewest misdeeds�察�and
that in action and boldness Caius came far short of Cleomenes。
THE END