握握弌傍利 > 凪麿窮徨慕 > the crisis in russia(躯忽裡字) >

及4嫗

the crisis in russia(躯忽裡字)-及4嫗

弌傍�� the crisis in russia(躯忽裡字) 忖方�� 耽匈3500忖

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��




the towns�察�and also ��as a result of the lack of imported materials�察�and so of 

variety and amount in the salable manufactures of the towns�� without the 

usual incentives to market food in exchange for other wares�察�an industrial 

population unable to   keep its strength   for lack   of food�察�unable to earn   a 

livelihood for lack of materials�察�and so unable to make good by imports 

from abroad the failure of productivity at home 。; 

       Russia     is  an  emphasized       engraving�察    �in   which    every    line   of  that 

picture     is  bitten  in   with   repeated     washes    of   acid。   Several    new    lines�察�

however�察  �are   added   to   the   drawing�察  �for   in   Russia   the   processes   at   work 

elsewhere have gone further than in the rest of Europe�察�and it is possible to 

see   dimly�察  �in   faint   outline�察  �the   new   stage   of   decay   which   is   threatened。 

The struggle to arrest decay is the real crisis of the revolution�察�of Russia�察�

and�察  �not   impossibly�察  �of   Europe。      For   each   country   that   develops   to   the 



                                                 13 


´ Page 14´

                                  THE CRISIS IN RUSSIA 



end in this direction is a country lost to the economic comity of Europe。 

And�察�as one country follows another over the brink�察�so will the remaining 

countries be faced by conditions of increasingly narrow self´dependence�察�

in fact by the very conditions which in Russia�察�so far�察�have received their 

clearest�察�most forcible illustration。 



              THE SHORTAGE OF MEN 



     In   the preceding   chapter   I   wrote of   Russia's   many  wants�察 �and   of   the 

processes   visibly  at   work�察  �tending   to   make   her   condition   worse   and   not 

better。     But I wrote of things�察�not of people。            I wrote of the shortage of 

this and of that�察�but not of the most serious of all shortages�察�which�察�while 

itself   largely   due   to   those   already   discussed�察  �daily   intensifies   them�察  �and 

points   the   way   to   that   further   stage   of   decay   which   is   threatened   in   the 

near future in Russia�察�and�察�in the more distant future in Europe。                 I did not 

write of the shortage deterioration of labor。 

       Shortage of labor is not peculiar to Russia。            It is among the postwar 

phenomena   common   to   all   countries。          The   war   and   its   accompanying 

eases have   cost   Europe�察 �including   Russia�察 �an   enormous   number  of   able´ 

bodied     men。    Many   millions       of  others   have    lost  the  habit   of  regular 

work。German industrialists complain that they cannot get labor�察�and that 

when   they   get   it�察  �it   is   not   productive。 I   heard   complaints   on   the   same 

subject   in   England。      But   just   as   the  economic   crisis�察  �due    in  the  first 

instance to the war and the isolation it imposed�察�has gone further in Russia 

than    elsewhere�察    �so   the  shortage     of  labor�察  �at  present    a  handicap�察    �an 

annoyance in more fortunate countries�察�is in Russia perhaps the greatest of 

the   national   dangers。     Shortage   of   labor   cannot   be   measured   simply   by 

the decreasing numbers of the workmen。                If it takes two workmen as long 

to do a particular job in 1920 as it took one man to do it in 1914�察�then�察�

even if the     number of workman has remained the same�察�the actual supply 

of labor has been halved。          And in Russia the situation is worse than that。 

For example�察�in the group of State metal´working factories�察�those�察�in fact 

which may be considered as the weapon with which Russia is trying to cut 



                                                14 


´ Page 15´

                                   THE CRISIS IN RUSSIA 



her way out of her transport difficulties�察�apart from the fact that there were 

in 19l6 81��600 workmen�察�whereas in 1920 there are only 42��500�察�labor has 

deteriorated   in   the   most   appalling   manner。  In   1916   in   these   factories   92 

per cent。 of the nominal working            hours were actually kept�察�in 1920 work 

goes   on   during   only  60   per   cent。  of   the   nominal   hours。   It   is   estimated 

that the labor of a single workman produces now only one quarter of what 

it   produced     in  1916。    To    take   another    example�察    �also   from    workmen 

engaged in transport�察�that is to say�察�in the most important of all work at the 

present   time�此  �in   the   Moscow   junction   of   the   Moscow   Kazan   Railway�察�

between      November       1st  and   February     29th    ��1920���察  �292    workmen      and 

clerks   missed   12��048   working   days�察  �being   absent�察  �on   in   average�察  �forty 

days per man in the four months。               In Moscow passenger´station on this 

line�察  �22   workmen   missed   in   November   106   days�察  �in   December   273�察  �in 

January 338�察�and in February 380�察�in an appalling 

     crescendo      further    illustrated   by   the  wagon      department�察    �where     28 

workmen        missed    in   November       104   days    and   in   February     500。    In 

November   workmen   absented   themselves   for   single   days。             In   February 

the same   workmen   were   absent   for the   greater   part   of   the   month。        The 

invariable   excuse   was   illness。     Many  cases   of   illness   there   undoubtedly 

were�察�since this period was the worst of the typhus epidemic�察�but besides 

illness�察�and besides mere obvious idleness which no doubt accounts for a 

certain   proportion   of   illegitimate   holidays�察  �there   is   another   explanation 

which goes nearer the root of the matter。              Much of the time filched from 

the State was in all probability spent in expeditions in search of food。 In 

Petrograd�察     �the   Council    of   Public    Economy      complain      that  there   is  a 

tendency to   turn   the eight´hour  day  into   a four´hour day。            Attempts   are 

being     made     to   arrest   this  tendency      by   making     an   additional     food 

allowance conditional  on   the  actual   fulfilment   of   working days。             In   the 

Donetz coal basin�察�the monthly output per man was in 1914 750 poods�察�in 

1916   615   poods�察  �in   1919   240   poods   ��figures   taken   from   Ekaterinoslav 

Government���察       �and    in  1920    theoutput     per   man    is  estimated     at  being 

something near 220 poods。 In the shale mines on the Volga�察�where food 

conditions   are   comparatively   good�察  �productivity   is   comparatively   high。 

Thus in a small mine near Simbirsk there are 230 workmen�察�of' whom 50 



                                                15 


´ Page 16´

                                   THE CRISIS IN RUSSIA 



to 60 are skilled。      The output for the unskilled is 28。9 poods in a shift�察�for 

the skilled 68。3。      But even there 25 per cent。 of the workmen are regular 

absentees�察�and actually the mine works only 17 or 18 days in a month�察�that 

is�察�70 per cent。 of the normal number of working days。                  The remaining 30 

per cent。 of normal working time is spent by the workmen in getting food。 

Another   small   mine   in   the   same   district   is   worked   entirely   by   unskilled 

labor�察�the wokers   being peasants   from the   neighboring villages。                 In   this 

mine   the   productivity   per   man   is   less�察  �but   all   the   men   work   full   time。 

They   do   not   have   to   waste   time   in   securing   food�察  �because�察  �being   local 

peasants�察    �they   are   supplied     by   their  own     villages   and    families。    In 

Moscow and Petrograd food is far more difficult to secure�察�more time is 

wasted on that hopeless task�察�even with that waste of time�察�the workman is 

not properly fed�察�and it cannot be wondered at that his productivity is low。 

       Something�察�no doubt�察�is due to the natural character of the Russians�察�

which led Trotsky to define man as an animal 

     distinguished by laziness。          Russians are   certainly lazy�察�and   probably 

owe     to  their  climate    their   remarkable     incapacity   for    prolonged     effort。 

The   Russian   climate   is   such that   over   large   areas of   Russia   the   Russian 

peasant is accustomed�察�and has been accustomed for hundreds of years�察�to 

perform prodigies of labor during two short periods of sowing and harvest�察�

and to spend the immensely long and monotonous winter in a hibernation 

like    that  of   the   snake    or  the   dormouse。       There     is  a  much     greater 

difference between a Russian workman's normal output and that of which 

he is capable for a short time if he sets himself to it�察�than there is between 

the   normal   and   exceptional   output   of   an   Englishman�察  �whose   temperate 

climate has not taught him to regard a great part of the year as a period of 

mere     waiting    for   and   resting   from    the  extraordinary      effort   of  a  few 

weeks。��*��   �В�*��Given   any   particular   motive�察  �any   particula   enthusiasm�察  �or 

visible�察�desirable object�察�even the hungry Russian workmen of to´day are 

capable of sudden and temporary increase of output。 The ;Saturdayings; 

��see p。 119�� provide endless illustrations of this。              They had something in 

the character   of   a picnic�察  �they  were   novel�察  �they  were   out of   the   routine�察�

and the productivity of labor during a ;Saturdaying; was invariably higher 

than    on   a  weekday。      For     example�察    �there   is  a  shortage    of  paper    for 



                                                16 


´ Page 17´

                                   THE CRISIS IN RUSSIA 



cigarettes。     People roll cigarettes in old newspapers。                It occurred to the 

Central Committee of the Papermakers' Union to organize a ;Sundaying; 

with the object of sending cigarette paper to the soldiers in the Red Army。 

Six    factories    took   part。   Here     is   a  table   showing    the   output   of  these 

factories during the ;Sundaying; and the average weekday output。                           The 

figures are in poods。 

                                                Made       on               Average       week 

Factory                           the Sunday            Day Output 

     Krasnogorodskaya。。。。。。。。。615。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。450 

Griaznovskaya。。。。。。。。。。。。。65。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。45 

Medianskaya。。。。。。。。。。。。。。105。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。90 

Dobruzhskaya。。。。。。。。。。。。。186。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。250 

Belgiiskaya。。。。。。。。。。。。。。127。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。85 

Ropshinskaya。。。。。。。。。。。。。。85。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。55�А�

       But    this  uneven     working      temperament       was    characteristic     of   the 

Russian      before    the   war   as   well   as   now。    It   has   been    said 

卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��1�� 家��1��

低辛嬬浪散議