握握弌傍利 > 凪麿窮徨慕 > prior analytics >

及8嫗

prior analytics-及8嫗

弌傍�� prior analytics 忖方�� 耽匈3500忖

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��






true to say that that which necessarily does not belong to some of the



As may possibly not belong to any A�察�just as it is not true to say



that what necessarily belongs to some A may possibly belong to all



A。 If any one then should claim that because it is not possible for



C to belong to all D�察�it necessarily does not belong to some D�察�he



would make a false assumption�此�for it does belong to all D�察�but



because in some cases it belongs necessarily�察�therefore we say that it



is not possible for it to belong to all。 Hence both the propositions



'A necessarily belongs to some B' and 'A necessarily does not belong



to some B' are opposed to the proposition 'A belongs to all B'。



Similarly also they are opposed to the proposition 'A may belong to no



B'。 It is clear then that in relation to what is possible and not



possible�察�in the sense originally defined�察�we must assume�察�not that



A necessarily belongs to some B�察�but that A necessarily does not



belong to some B。 But if this is assumed�察�no absurdity results��



consequently no syllogism。 It is clear from what has been said that



the negative proposition is not convertible。



  This being proved�察�suppose it possible that A may belong to no B and



to all C。 By means of conversion no syllogism will result�此�for the



major premiss�察�as has been said�察�is not convertible。 Nor can a proof



be obtained by a reductio ad absurdum�此�for if it is assumed that B can



belong to all C�察�no false consequence results�此�for A may belong both



to all C and to no C。 In general�察�if there is a syllogism�察�it is clear



that its conclusion will be problematic because neither of the



premisses is assertoric�察�and this must be either affirmative or



negative。 But neither is possible。 Suppose the conclusion is



affirmative�此�it will be proved by an example that the predicate cannot



belong to the subject。 Suppose the conclusion is negative�此�it will



be proved that it is not problematic but necessary。 Let A be white��



B man�察�C horse。 It is possible then for A to belong to all of the



one and to none of the other。 But it is not possible for B to belong



nor not to belong to C。 That it is not possible for it to belong�察�is



clear。 For no horse is a man。 Neither is it possible for it not to



belong。 For it is necessary that no horse should be a man�察�but the



necessary we found to be different from the possible。 No syllogism



then results。 A similar proof can be given if the major premiss is



negative�察�the minor affirmative�察�or if both are affirmative or



negative。 The demonstration can be made by means of the same terms。



And whenever one premiss is universal�察�the other particular�察�or both



are particular or indefinite�察�or in whatever other way the premisses



can be altered�察�the proof will always proceed through the same



terms。 Clearly then�察�if both the premisses are problematic�察�no



syllogism results。







                                18







  But if one premiss is assertoric�察�the other problematic�察�if the



affirmative is assertoric and the negative problematic no syllogism



will be possible�察�whether the premisses are universal or particular。



The proof is the same as above�察�and by means of the same terms。 But



when the affirmative premiss is problematic�察�and the negative



assertoric�察�we shall have a syllogism。 Suppose A belongs to no B��



but can belong to all C。 If the negative proposition is converted�察�B



will belong to no A。 But ex hypothesi can belong to all C�此�so a



syllogism is made�察�proving by means of the first figure that B may



belong to no C。 Similarly also if the minor premiss is negative。 But



if both premisses are negative�察�one being assertoric�察�the other



problematic�察�nothing follows necessarily from these premisses as



they stand�察�but if the problematic premiss is converted into its



complementary affirmative a syllogism is formed to prove that B may



belong to no C�察�as before�此�for we shall again have the first figure。



But if both premisses are affirmative�察�no syllogism will be



possible。 This arrangement of terms is possible both when the relation



is positive�察�e。g。 health�察�animal�察�man�察�and when it is negative�察�e。g。



health�察�horse�察�man。



  The same will hold good if the syllogisms are particular。 Whenever



the affirmative proposition is assertoric�察�whether universal or



particular�察�no syllogism is possible ��this is proved similarly and



by the same examples as above���察�but when the negative proposition is



assertoric�察�a conclusion can be drawn by means of conversion�察�as



before。 Again if both the relations are negative�察�and the assertoric



proposition is universal�察�although no conclusion follows from the



actual premisses�察�a syllogism can be obtained by converting the



problematic premiss into its complementary affirmative as before。



But if the negative proposition is assertoric�察�but particular�察�no



syllogism is possible�察�whether the other premiss is affirmative or



negative。 Nor can a conclusion be drawn when both premisses are



indefinite�察�whether affirmative or negative�察�or particular。 The



proof is the same and by the same terms。







                                19







  If one of the premisses is necessary�察�the other problematic�察�then if



the negative is necessary a syllogistic conclusion can be drawn�察�not



merely a negative problematic but also a negative assertoric



conclusion�察�but if the affirmative premiss is necessary�察�no conclusion



is possible。 Suppose that A necessarily belongs to no B�察�but may



belong to all C。 If the negative premiss is converted B will belong to



no A�此�but A ex hypothesi is capable of belonging to all C�此�so once



more a conclusion is drawn by the first figure that B may belong to no



C。 But at the same time it is clear that B will not belong to any C。



For assume that it does�此�then if A cannot belong to any B�察�and B



belongs to some of the Cs�察�A cannot belong to some of the Cs�此�but ex



hypothesi it may belong to all。 A similar proof can be given if the



minor premiss is negative。 Again let the affirmative proposition be



necessary�察�and the other problematic�察�i。e。 suppose that A may belong



to no B�察�but necessarily belongs to all C。 When the terms are arranged



in this way�察�no syllogism is possible。 For ��1�� it sometimes turns



out that B necessarily does not belong to C。 Let A be white�察�B man��



C swan。 White then necessarily belongs to swan�察�but may belong to no



man�察�and man necessarily belongs to no swan�察�Clearly then we cannot



draw a problematic conclusion�察�for that which is necessary is



admittedly distinct from that which is possible。 ��2�� Nor again can



we draw a necessary conclusion�此�for that presupposes that both



premisses are necessary�察�or at any rate the negative premiss。 ��3��



Further it is possible also�察�when the terms are so arranged�察�that B



should belong to C�此�for nothing prevents C falling under B�察�A being



possible for all B�察�and necessarily belonging to C�察�e。g。 if C stands



for 'awake'�察�B for 'animal'�察�A for 'motion'。 For motion necessarily



belongs to what is awake�察�and is possible for every animal�此�and



everything that is awake is animal。 Clearly then the conclusion cannot



be the negative assertion�察�if the relation must be positive when the



terms are related as above。 Nor can the opposite affirmations be



established�此�consequently no syllogism is possible。 A similar proof is



possible if the major premiss is affirmative。



  But if the premisses are similar in quality�察�when they are



negative a syllogism can always be formed by converting the



problematic premiss into its complementary affirmative as before。



Suppose A necessarily does not belong to B�察�and possibly may not



belong to C�此�if the premisses are converted B belongs to no A�察�and A



may possibly belong to all C�此�thus we have the first figure。 Similarly



if the minor premiss is negative。 But if the premisses are affirmative



there cannot be a syllogism。 Clearly the conclusion cannot be a



negative assertoric or a negative necessary proposition because no



negative premiss has been laid down either in the assertoric or in the



necessary mode。 Nor can the conclusion be a problematic negative



proposition。 For if the terms are so related�察�there are cases in which



B necessarily will not belong to C�察�e。g。 suppose that A is white�察�B



swan�察�C man。 Nor can the opposite affirmations be established�察�since



we have shown a case in which B necessarily does not belong to C。 A



syllogism then is not possible at all。



  Similar relations will obtain in particular syllogisms。 For whenever



the negative proposition is universal and necessary�察�a syllogism



will always be possible to prove both a problematic and a negative



assertoric proposition ��the proof proceeds by conversion���察�but when



the affirmative proposition is universal and necessary�察�no syllogistic



conclusion can be drawn。 This can be proved in the same way as for



universal propositions�察�and by the same terms。 Nor is a syllogistic



conclusion possible when both premisses are affirmative�此�this also may



be proved as above。 But when both premisses are negative�察�and the



premiss that definitely disconnects two terms is universal and



necessary�察�though nothing follows necessarily from the premisses as



they are stated�察�a conclusion can be drawn as above if the problematic



premiss is converted into its complementary affirmative。 But if both



are indefinite or particular�察�no syllogism can be formed。 The same



proof will serve�察�and the same terms。



  It is clear then from what has been said that if the universal and



negative premiss is necessary�察�a syllogism is always possible�察�proving



not merely a negative problematic�察�but also a negative assertoric



proposition�察�but if the affirmative premiss is necessary no conclusion



can be drawn。 It is clear too that a syllogism is possible or not



under the same conditions whether the mode of the premisses is



assertoric or necessary。 And it is clear that all the syllogisms are



imperfect�察�and are completed by means of the figures mentioned。







                                20



  In the last figure a syllogism is possible whether both or only



one of the premisses is problematic。 When the premisses are



problematic the conclusion will be problematic�察�and also when one



premiss is problematic�察�the other assertoric。 But when the other



premiss is necessary�察�if it is affirmative the conclusion will be



neither necessary or assertoric�察�but if it is negative the syllogism

卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��4�� 家��3��

低辛嬬浪散議