the ethics(part iv)-及7嫗
梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
III��xxxix。 It is there shown�察�that an emotion can only be restrained by an
emotion stronger than�察�and contrary to itself�察�and that men avoid inflicting
injury through fear of incurring a greater injury themselves。
On this law society can be established�察�so long as it keeps in its own
hand the right�察�possessed by everyone�察�of avenging injury�察�and pronouncing
on good and evil�察�and provided it also possesses the power to lay down a
general rule of conduct�察�and to pass laws sanctioned�察�not by reason�察�which
is powerless in restraining emotion�察�but by threats ��IV��xvii。Note��。 Such a
society established with laws and the power of preserving itself is called
a State�察�while those who live under its protection are called citizens。 We
may readily understand that there is in the state of nature nothing�察�which
by universal consent is pronounced good or bad�察�for in the state of nature
everyone thinks solely of his own advantage�察�and according to his
disposition�察�with reference only to his individual advantage�察�decides
what is good or bad�察�being bound by no law to anyone besides himself。
In the state of nature�察�therefore�察�sin is inconceivable�察�it can only
exist in a state�察�where good and evil are pronounced on by common consent�察�
and where everyone is bound to obey the State authority。 Sin�察�then�察�
is nothing else but disobedience�察�which is therefore punished by the right
of the State only。 Obedience�察�on the other hand�察�is set down as merit�察�
inasmuch as a man is thought worthy of merit�察�if he takes delight in the
advantages which a State provides。
Again�察�in the state of nature�察�no one is by common consent master of
anything�察�nor is there anything in nature�察�which can be said to belong to
one man rather than another�此�all things are common to all。 Hence�察�in the
state of nature�察�we can conceive no wish to render to every man his own�察�
or to deprive a man of that which belongs to him�察�in other words�察�there is
nothing in the state of nature answering to justice and injustice。 Such
ideas are only possible in a social state�察�when it is decreed by common
consent what belongs to one man and what to another。
From all these considerations it is evident�察�that justice and
injustice�察�sin and merit�察�are extrinsic ideas�察�and not attributes which
display the nature of the mind。 But I have said enough。
Prop。 XXXVIII。 Whatsoever disposes the human
body�察�so as to render it capable of being
affected in an increased number of ways�察�or
of affecting external bodies in an increased
number of ways�察�is useful to man �察�and is so�察�
in proportion as the body is thereby rendered
more capable of being affected or affecting
other bodies in an increased number of ways�察�
contrariwise�察�whatsoever renders the body less
capable in this respect is hurtful to man。
Proof。´ Whatsoever thus increases the capabilities of the body increases
also the mind's capability of perception ��II��xiv。���察�therefore�察�whatsoever
thus disposes the body and thus renders it capable�察�is necessarily good or
useful ��IV��xxvi。�察�IV��xxvii。���察�and is so in proportion to the extent to
which it can render the body capable�察�contrariwise ��II��xiv。�察�IV��xxvi。�察�
IV��xxvii。���察�it is hurtful�察�if it renders the body in this respect less
capable。 Q。E。D。
Prop。 XXXIX。 Whatsoever brings about
the preservation of the proportion of
motion and rest�察�which the parts of
the human body mutually possess�察�is
good�察�contrariwise�察�whatsoever causes
a change in such proportion is bad。
Proof。´ The human body needs many other bodies for its preservation
��II��Post。iv。��。 But that which constitutes the specific reality ��forma��
of a human body is�察�that its parts communicate their several motions
one to another in a certain fixed proportion ��Def。 before Lemma iv。 after
II��xiii。��。 Therefore�察�whatsoever brings about the preservation of the
proportion between motion and rest�察�which the parts of the human body
mutually possess�察�preserves the specific reality of the human body�察�and
consequently renders the human body capable of being affected in many ways
and of affecting external bodies in many ways�察�consequently it is good
��by the last Prop。��。 Again�察�whatsoever brings about a change in the
aforesaid proportion causes the human body to assume another specific
character�察�in other words ��see Preface to this Part towards the end�察�
though the point is indeed self´evident���察�to be destroyed�察�and
consequently totally incapable of being affected in an increased
numbers of ways�察�therefore it is bad。 Q。E。D。
Note。´ The extent to which such causes can injure or be of service to the
mind will be explained in the Fifth Part。 But I would here remark that I
consider that a body undergoes death�察�when the proportion of motion and
rest which obtained mutually among its several parts is changed。 For I do
not venture to deny that a human body�察�while keeping the circulation of
the blood and other properties�察�wherein the life of a body is thought to
consist�察�may none the less be changed into another nature totally different
from its own。 There is no reason�察�which compels me to maintain that a body
does not die�察�unless it becomes a corpse�察�nay�察�experience would seem to
point to the opposite conclusion。 It sometimes happens�察�that a man
undergoes such changes�察�that I should hardly call him the same。 As I have
heard tell of a certain Spanish poet�察�who had been seized with sickness�察�
and though he recovered therefrom yet remained so oblivious of his past
life�察�that he would not believe the plays and tragedies he had
written to be his own�此�indeed�察�he might have been taken for a grown´up
child�察�if he had also forgotten his native tongue。 If this instance seems
incredible�察�what shall we say of infants�拭�A man of ripe age deems their
nature so unlike his own�察�that he can only be persuaded that he too has
been an infant by the analogy of other men。 However�察�I prefer to leave such
questions undiscussed�察�lest I should give ground to the superstitious for
raising new issues。
Prop。 XL。 Whatsoever conduces to man's
social life�察�or causes men to live
together in harmony�察�is useful�察�whereas
whatsoever brings discord into a State is bad。
Proof。´ For whatsoever causes men to live together in harmony also causes
them to live according to reason ��IV��xxxv。���察�and is therefore ��IV��xxvi。
and IV��xxvii。�� good�察�and ��for the same reason�� whatsoever brings about
discord is bad。 Q。E。D。
Prop。 XLI。 Pleasure in itself is not
bad but good�此�contrariwise�察�pain in
itself is bad。
Proof。´ Pleasure ��III��xi。&Note�� is emotion�察�whereby the body's power of
activity is increased or helped�察�pain is emotion�察�whereby the body's power
of activity is diminished or checked�察�therefore ��IV��xxxviii。�� pleasure in
itself is good�察�&c。 Q。E。D。
Prop。 XLII。 Mirth cannot be excessive�察�
but is always good�察�contrariwise�察�
Melancholy is always bad。
Proof。´ Mirth ��see its Def。 in III��xi。Note�� is pleasure。 which�察�in so
far as it is referred to the body�察�consists in all parts of the body being
affected equally�此�that is ��III��xi。���察�the body's power of activity is
increased or aided in such a manner�察�that the several parts maintain their
former proportion of motion and rest�察�therefore Mirth is always good
��IV。 xxxix。���察�and cannot be excessive。 But Melancholy ��see its Def。 in
the same note to III��xi。Note�� is pain�察�which�察�in so far as it is referred
to the body�察�consists in the absolute decrease or hindrance of the body's
power of activity�察�therefore ��IV��xxxviii。�� it is always bad。 Q。E。D。
Prop。 XLIII。 Stimulation may be excessive
and bad�察�on the other hand�察�grief may be
good�察�in so far as stimulation or pleasure
is bad。
Proof。´ Localized pleasure or stimulation ��titillatio�� is pleasure�察�which�察�
in so far as it is referred to the body�察�consists in one or some of its
parts being affected more than the rest ��see its Definition�察�III��xi。Note���察�
the power of this emotion may be sufficient to overcome other actions of
the body ��IV��vi。���察�and may remain obstinately fixed therein�察�thus rendering
it incapable of being affected in a variety of other ways�此�therefore
��IV��xxxviii。�� it may be bad。 Again�察�grief�察�which is pain�察�cannot as such
be good ��IV��xli。��。 But�察�as its force and increase is defined by the power
of an external cause compared with our own ��IV��v。���察�we can conceive
infinite degrees and modes of strength in this emotion ��IV��iii。���察�
we can�察�therefore�察�conceive it as capable of restraining stimulation�察�
and preventing its becoming excessive�察�and hindering the body's
capabilities�察�thus�察�to this extent�察�it will be good。 Q。E。D。
Prop。 XLIV。 Love and desire may be excessive。
Proof。´ Love is pleasure�察�accompanied by the idea of an external cause
��Def_of_Emotions��vi。���察�therefore stimulation�察�accompanied by the idea of
an external cause is love ��III��xi。Note���察�hence love maybe excessive。
Again�察�the strength of desire varies in proportion to the emotion from
which it arises ��III��xxxvii。��。 Now emotion may overcome all the rest of
men's actions ��IV��vi。���察�so�察�therefore�察�can desire�察�which arises from the
same emotion�察�overcome all other desires�察�and become excessive�察�as we
showed in the last proposition concerning stimulation。
Note。´ Mirth�察�which I have stated to be good�察�can be conceived more easily
than it can be observed。 For the emotions�察�whereby we are daily assailed�察�
are generally referred to some part of the body which is affected more than
the rest�察�hence the emotions are generally excessive�察�and so fix the mind
in the contemplation of one object�察�that it is unable to think of others�察�
and although men�察�as a rule�察�are a prey to many emotions ´ and very few
are found who are always assailed by one and the same ´ yet there are
cases�察�where one and the same emotion remains obstinately fixed。 We
sometimes see men so absorbed in one object�察�that�察�although it be not
present�察�they think they have it before them�察�when this is the case with a
man who is not asleep�察�we say he is delirious or mad�察�nor are those persons
who are inflamed with love�察�and who dream all night and all day about
nothing but their mistress�察�or some woman�察�considered as less mad�察�for
they are made objects of ridicule。 But when a miser thinks of nothing but
gain or money�察�or when an ambitious man thinks of nothing but glory�察�they
are not reckoned to be mad�察�because they are generally harmful�察�and are