握握弌傍利 > 凪麿窮徨慕 > misc writings and speeches(致帽針傍嚥亟) >

及34嫗

misc writings and speeches(致帽針傍嚥亟)-及34嫗

弌傍�� misc writings and speeches(致帽針傍嚥亟) 忖方�� 耽匈3500忖

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��




Europe   are   full of   errors�此    �but he   writes   of   times   with   respect to   which 

almost     every    other    writer   has   been    in  the   wrong�察    �and�察  �therefore�察   �by 

resolutely deviating from his predecessors�察�he is often in the right。 

     Almost all   the modern historians of Greece   have shown the grossest 

ignorance      of   the  most    obvious     phenomena       of   human     nature。    In  their 

representations       the   generals    and   statesmen      of  antiquity    are   absolutely 

divested of all individuality。         They are personifications�察�they are passions�察�

talents�察�opinions�察�virtues�察�vices�察�but not men。              Inconsistency is a thing of 

which these writers have no notion。              That a man may have been liberal in 

his youth   and   avaricious   in   his   age�察 �cruel   to   one   enemy  and   merciful   to 

another�察�is to them utterly inconceivable。              If the facts be undeniable�察�they 

suppose some strange and deep design�察�in order to explain what�察�as every 

one who has observed his own mind knows�察�needs no explanation at all。 

This   is   a   mode   of   writing   very   acceptable   to   the   multitude   who   have 

always been accustomed to make gods and daemons out of men very little 

better   or   worse   than   themselves�察  �but   it   appears   contemptible   to   all   who 

have watched the changes of human characterto all who have observed 



                                              137 


´ Page 138´

             THE MISCELLANEOUS WRITINGS AND SPEECHES OF LORD MACAULAY 



the influence of time�察�of circumstances�察�and of associates�察�on mankindto 

all who have seen a hero in the gout�察�a democrat in the church�察�a pedant in 

love�察�or a philosopher in liquor。           This practice of painting in nothing but 

black and white is unpardonable even in the drama。                   It is the great fault of 

Alfieri�察  �and   how   much   it   injures   the   effect   of   his   compositions   will   be 

obvious   to   every   one   who   will   compare   his   Rosmunda   with   the   Lady 

Macbeth of Shakspeare。            The one is a wicked woman�察�the other is a fiend。 

Her   only   feeling   is   hatred�察  �all   her   words   are   curses。    We   are   at   once 

shocked and fatigued by the spectacle of such raving cruelty�察�excited by no 

provocation�察�repeatedly changing its object�察�and constant in nothing but in 

its in´ extinguishable thirst for blood。 

     In history this error is far more disgraceful。             Indeed�察�there is no fault 

which so completely ruins a narrative in the opinion of a judicious reader。 

We   know  that   the   line   of   demarcation   between   good   and   bad   men   is   so 

faintly   marked   as   often   to   elude   the   most   careful   investigation   of   those 

who have the best opportunities for judging。                 Public men�察�above all�察�are 

surrounded   with   so   many   temptations   and   difficulties   that   some   doubt 

must almost always hang over their real dispositions and intentions。                      The 

lives of Pym�察�Cromwell�察�Monk�察�Clarendon�察�Marlborough�察�Burnet�察�Walpole�察�

are    well   known      to  us。   We     are   acquainted      with   their   actions�察   �their 

speeches�察      �their   writings�察    �we    have    abundance       of   letters   and    well´ 

authenticated anecdotes relating to them�此�yet what candid man will venture 

very positively to say which of them were honest and which of them were 

dishonest men�拭        �It appears easier to pronounce decidedly upon the great 

characters of antiquity�察�not because we have greater means of discovering 

truth�察  �but   simply   because   we   have   less   means   of   detecting   error。       The 

modern       historians    of  Greece     have    forgotten     this。   Their     heroes    and 

villains   are   as   consistent   in   all   their   sayings   and   doings   as   the   cardinal 

virtues and the deadly sins in an allegory。                We should as soon expect a 

good   action   from   giant   Slay´good   in   Bunyan   as   from   Dionysius�察  �and   a 

crime   of   Epaminondas   would   seem   as   incongruous   as   a   faux´pas   of   the 

grave and comely damsel called Discretion�察�who answered the bell at the 

door of the house Beautiful。 

     This    error   was    partly   the  cause    and   partly   the   effect   of  the   high 



                                              138 


´ Page 139´

            THE MISCELLANEOUS WRITINGS AND SPEECHES OF LORD MACAULAY 



estimation   in   which   the   later   ancient   writers   have   been   held   by   modern 

scholars。      Those   French   and   English   authors   who   have   treated   of   the 

affairs of Greece have generally turned with contempt from the simple and 

natural     narrations    of   Thucydides      and    Xenophon       to  the   extravagant 

representations of Plutarch�察�Diodorus�察�Curtius�察�and other romancers of the 

same class��men who described military operations without ever   having 

handled      a   sword�察   �and    applied    to   the   seditions    of   little  republics 

speculations formed by observation on an empire which covered half the 

known   world。       Of   liberty   they   knew   nothing。     It   was   to   them   a   great 

mysterya      superhuman        enjoyment。       They     ranted    about    liberty   and 

patriotism�察�from the same cause which leads monks to talk more ardently 

than   other   men   about   love   and   women。        A   wise   man   values   political 

liberty�察  �because   it   secures   the   persons   and   the   possessions   of   citizens�察�

because it tends to prevent the extravagance of rulers�察�and the corruption 

of   judges�察   �because    it  gives   birth  to  useful    sciences    and   elegant   arts�察�

because it excites the industry and increases the comforts of all classes of 

society。     These   theorists   imagined   that   it   possessed   something   eternally 

and    intrinsically    good�察  �distinct   from    the  blessings    which     it  generally 

produced。      They considered it not as a means but as an end�察�an end to be 

attained at any cost。       Their favourite heroes are those who have sacrificed�察�

for   the   mere   name   of   freedom�察  �the   prosperitythe   securitythe   justice 

from which freedom derives its value。 

     There   is   another   remarkable   characteristic   of   these   writers�察  �in   which 

their modern worshippers have carefully imitated thema great fondness 

for   good   stories。    The   most   established   facts�察  �dates�察  �and   characters   are 

never   suffered     to  come   into   competition   with   a   splendid   saying�察  �or   a 

romantic   exploit。      The   early   historians   have   left   us   natural   and   simple 

descriptions of the great events which they witnessed�察�and the great men 

with whom they associated。            When we read the account which Plutarch 

and   Rollin   have   given   of   the   same   period�察  �we   scarcely   know   our   old 

acquaintance   again�察      �we   are  utterly   confounded      by   the  melo´    dramatic 

effect of the narration�察�and the sublime coxcombry of the characters。 

     These     are  the   principal   errors   into   which    the  predecessors      of  Mr 

Mitford have fallen�察�and from most of these he is free。               His faults are of a 



                                             139 


´ Page 140´

             THE MISCELLANEOUS WRITINGS AND SPEECHES OF LORD MACAULAY 



completely   different   description。         It   is   to   be   hoped   that   the   students   of 

history   may   now   be   saved�察  �like   Dorax   in   Dryden's   play�察  �by   swallowing 

two   conflicting   poisons�察  �each   of   which   may   serve   as   an   antidote   to   the 

other。 

     The first and most important difference between Mr Mitford and those 

who have preceded him is in his narration。                 Here the advantage lies�察�for 

the   most   part�察 �on   his   side。  His principle   is   to   follow   the   contemporary 

historians�察  �to   look   with   doubt   on   all   statements   which   are   not   in   some 

degree      confirmed      by   them�察    �and   absolutely      to  reject    all  which     are 

contradicted by them。           While he retains the guidance of some writer in 

whom he can place confidence�察�he goes on excellently。                     When he loses it�察�

he falls to the level�察�or perhaps below the level�察�of the writers whom he so 

much despises�此�he is as absurd as they�察�and very much duller。 It is really 

amusing to   observe how  he proceeds   with his narration when he has no 

better authority than poor Diodorus。             He is compelled to relate something�察�

yet    he   believes     nothing。     He     accompanies        every    fact   with   a   long 

statement of objections。          His account of the administration of Dionysius 

is   in   no   sense   a   history。 It   ought   to   be   entitled;Historic   doubts   as   to 

certain events�察�alleged to have taken place in Sicily。; 

     This    scepticism�察    �however�察    �like   that  of   some    great   legal   characters 

almost as sceptical as himself�察�vanishes whenever his political partialities 

interfere。     He     is  a  vehement      admirer     of   tyranny    and    oligarchy�察   �and 

considers no evidence as feeble which can be brought forward in favour of 

those forms of government。 Democracy he hates with a perfect hatred�察�a 

hatred     which�察   �in  the   first  volume     of  his   history�察  �appears    only    in  his 

episodes   and      reflections�察   �but  which�察    �in  those   parts   where    he   has   less 

reverence for his guides�察�and can venture to take his own way�察�completely 

distorts even his narration。 

     In   taking   up   these   opinions�察  �I   have   no   doubt   that   Mr   Mitford   was 

influenced by the same love of singularity which led him to spell ;island; 

without   an   ;s�察─  �and   to   place   two   dots   over   the   last   letter   of   ;idea。; In 

truth�察�preceding historians have erred so monstrously on the other side that 

even the worst parts of Mr Mitford's book may be useful as a corrective。 

For a young gentleman who talks much about his country�察�tyrannicide�察�and 



                                              140 


´ Page 141´

             THE MISCELLANEOUS WRITINGS AND SPEECHES OF LORD MACAULAY 



Epaminondas�察  �this   work�察  �diluted   in   a   sufficient   quantity   of   Rollin   and 

Berthelemi�察�may be a very useful remedy。 

     The errors of both parties arise from an ignorance or a neglect of the 

fundamental       principles    of   political   science。    The     writers   on   one   side 

imagine popular government to be always a blessing�察�Mr Mitford omits no 

opportunity  of   assur

卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��3�� 家��3��

低辛嬬浪散議