misc writings and speeches(致帽針傍嚥亟)-及34嫗
梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
Europe are full of errors�此 �but he writes of times with respect to which
almost every other writer has been in the wrong�察 �and�察 �therefore�察 �by
resolutely deviating from his predecessors�察�he is often in the right。
Almost all the modern historians of Greece have shown the grossest
ignorance of the most obvious phenomena of human nature。 In their
representations the generals and statesmen of antiquity are absolutely
divested of all individuality。 They are personifications�察�they are passions�察�
talents�察�opinions�察�virtues�察�vices�察�but not men。 Inconsistency is a thing of
which these writers have no notion。 That a man may have been liberal in
his youth and avaricious in his age�察 �cruel to one enemy and merciful to
another�察�is to them utterly inconceivable。 If the facts be undeniable�察�they
suppose some strange and deep design�察�in order to explain what�察�as every
one who has observed his own mind knows�察�needs no explanation at all。
This is a mode of writing very acceptable to the multitude who have
always been accustomed to make gods and daemons out of men very little
better or worse than themselves�察 �but it appears contemptible to all who
have watched the changes of human characterto all who have observed
137
´ Page 138´
THE MISCELLANEOUS WRITINGS AND SPEECHES OF LORD MACAULAY
the influence of time�察�of circumstances�察�and of associates�察�on mankindto
all who have seen a hero in the gout�察�a democrat in the church�察�a pedant in
love�察�or a philosopher in liquor。 This practice of painting in nothing but
black and white is unpardonable even in the drama。 It is the great fault of
Alfieri�察 �and how much it injures the effect of his compositions will be
obvious to every one who will compare his Rosmunda with the Lady
Macbeth of Shakspeare。 The one is a wicked woman�察�the other is a fiend。
Her only feeling is hatred�察 �all her words are curses。 We are at once
shocked and fatigued by the spectacle of such raving cruelty�察�excited by no
provocation�察�repeatedly changing its object�察�and constant in nothing but in
its in´ extinguishable thirst for blood。
In history this error is far more disgraceful。 Indeed�察�there is no fault
which so completely ruins a narrative in the opinion of a judicious reader。
We know that the line of demarcation between good and bad men is so
faintly marked as often to elude the most careful investigation of those
who have the best opportunities for judging。 Public men�察�above all�察�are
surrounded with so many temptations and difficulties that some doubt
must almost always hang over their real dispositions and intentions。 The
lives of Pym�察�Cromwell�察�Monk�察�Clarendon�察�Marlborough�察�Burnet�察�Walpole�察�
are well known to us。 We are acquainted with their actions�察 �their
speeches�察 �their writings�察 �we have abundance of letters and well´
authenticated anecdotes relating to them�此�yet what candid man will venture
very positively to say which of them were honest and which of them were
dishonest men�拭 �It appears easier to pronounce decidedly upon the great
characters of antiquity�察�not because we have greater means of discovering
truth�察 �but simply because we have less means of detecting error。 The
modern historians of Greece have forgotten this。 Their heroes and
villains are as consistent in all their sayings and doings as the cardinal
virtues and the deadly sins in an allegory。 We should as soon expect a
good action from giant Slay´good in Bunyan as from Dionysius�察 �and a
crime of Epaminondas would seem as incongruous as a faux´pas of the
grave and comely damsel called Discretion�察�who answered the bell at the
door of the house Beautiful。
This error was partly the cause and partly the effect of the high
138
´ Page 139´
THE MISCELLANEOUS WRITINGS AND SPEECHES OF LORD MACAULAY
estimation in which the later ancient writers have been held by modern
scholars。 Those French and English authors who have treated of the
affairs of Greece have generally turned with contempt from the simple and
natural narrations of Thucydides and Xenophon to the extravagant
representations of Plutarch�察�Diodorus�察�Curtius�察�and other romancers of the
same class��men who described military operations without ever having
handled a sword�察 �and applied to the seditions of little republics
speculations formed by observation on an empire which covered half the
known world。 Of liberty they knew nothing。 It was to them a great
mysterya superhuman enjoyment。 They ranted about liberty and
patriotism�察�from the same cause which leads monks to talk more ardently
than other men about love and women。 A wise man values political
liberty�察 �because it secures the persons and the possessions of citizens�察�
because it tends to prevent the extravagance of rulers�察�and the corruption
of judges�察 �because it gives birth to useful sciences and elegant arts�察�
because it excites the industry and increases the comforts of all classes of
society。 These theorists imagined that it possessed something eternally
and intrinsically good�察 �distinct from the blessings which it generally
produced。 They considered it not as a means but as an end�察�an end to be
attained at any cost。 Their favourite heroes are those who have sacrificed�察�
for the mere name of freedom�察 �the prosperitythe securitythe justice
from which freedom derives its value。
There is another remarkable characteristic of these writers�察 �in which
their modern worshippers have carefully imitated thema great fondness
for good stories。 The most established facts�察 �dates�察 �and characters are
never suffered to come into competition with a splendid saying�察 �or a
romantic exploit。 The early historians have left us natural and simple
descriptions of the great events which they witnessed�察�and the great men
with whom they associated。 When we read the account which Plutarch
and Rollin have given of the same period�察 �we scarcely know our old
acquaintance again�察 �we are utterly confounded by the melo´ dramatic
effect of the narration�察�and the sublime coxcombry of the characters。
These are the principal errors into which the predecessors of Mr
Mitford have fallen�察�and from most of these he is free。 His faults are of a
139
´ Page 140´
THE MISCELLANEOUS WRITINGS AND SPEECHES OF LORD MACAULAY
completely different description。 It is to be hoped that the students of
history may now be saved�察 �like Dorax in Dryden's play�察 �by swallowing
two conflicting poisons�察 �each of which may serve as an antidote to the
other。
The first and most important difference between Mr Mitford and those
who have preceded him is in his narration。 Here the advantage lies�察�for
the most part�察 �on his side。 His principle is to follow the contemporary
historians�察 �to look with doubt on all statements which are not in some
degree confirmed by them�察 �and absolutely to reject all which are
contradicted by them。 While he retains the guidance of some writer in
whom he can place confidence�察�he goes on excellently。 When he loses it�察�
he falls to the level�察�or perhaps below the level�察�of the writers whom he so
much despises�此�he is as absurd as they�察�and very much duller。 It is really
amusing to observe how he proceeds with his narration when he has no
better authority than poor Diodorus。 He is compelled to relate something�察�
yet he believes nothing。 He accompanies every fact with a long
statement of objections。 His account of the administration of Dionysius
is in no sense a history。 It ought to be entitled;Historic doubts as to
certain events�察�alleged to have taken place in Sicily。;
This scepticism�察 �however�察 �like that of some great legal characters
almost as sceptical as himself�察�vanishes whenever his political partialities
interfere。 He is a vehement admirer of tyranny and oligarchy�察 �and
considers no evidence as feeble which can be brought forward in favour of
those forms of government。 Democracy he hates with a perfect hatred�察�a
hatred which�察 �in the first volume of his history�察 �appears only in his
episodes and reflections�察 �but which�察 �in those parts where he has less
reverence for his guides�察�and can venture to take his own way�察�completely
distorts even his narration。
In taking up these opinions�察 �I have no doubt that Mr Mitford was
influenced by the same love of singularity which led him to spell ;island;
without an ;s�察─ �and to place two dots over the last letter of ;idea。; In
truth�察�preceding historians have erred so monstrously on the other side that
even the worst parts of Mr Mitford's book may be useful as a corrective。
For a young gentleman who talks much about his country�察�tyrannicide�察�and
140
´ Page 141´
THE MISCELLANEOUS WRITINGS AND SPEECHES OF LORD MACAULAY
Epaminondas�察 �this work�察 �diluted in a sufficient quantity of Rollin and
Berthelemi�察�may be a very useful remedy。
The errors of both parties arise from an ignorance or a neglect of the
fundamental principles of political science。 The writers on one side
imagine popular government to be always a blessing�察�Mr Mitford omits no
opportunity of assur