握握弌傍利 > 凪麿窮徨慕 > a treatise on parents and children(幻銚嚥徨溺廨籾冩梢) >

及7嫗

a treatise on parents and children(幻銚嚥徨溺廨籾冩梢)-及7嫗


梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��




Now no controversial subject can be taught dogmatically。                   He who knows 

only the official side of a controversy knows less than nothing of its nature。 

The abler a schoolmaster is�察�the more dangerous he is to his pupils unless 

they have the fullest opportunity of hearing another equally able person do 

his utmost to shake his authority and convict him of error。 

     At    present   such    teaching    is  very  unpopular。      It   does   not  exist   in 

schools�察�but every adult who derives his knowledge of public affairs from 

the newspapers can take in�察�at the cost of an extra halfpenny�察�two papers of 

opposite     politics。    Yet   the   ordinary    man    so  dislikes    having    his  mind 

unsettled�察  �as   he   calls   it�察  �that   he   angrily   refuses   to   allow   a   paper   which 

dissents from his views to be brought into his house。                Even at his club he 

resents    seeing    it�察 �and  excludes     it  if  it  happens   to  run   counter   to   the 

opinions of all the members。           The result is that his opinions are not worth 

considering。       A  churchman   who   never   reads The   Freethinker   very  soon 

has   no   more   real   religion   than   the   atheist   who   never   reads   The   Church 

Times。      The     attitude   is  the  same    in  both   cases�此   �they    want    to  hear 

nothing   good   of   their   enemies�察  �consequently   they   remain   enemies   and 

suffer    from    bad   blood    all  their  lives�察  �whereas     men    who    know     their 



                                                29 


´ Page 30´

                        A TREATISE ON PARENTS AND CHILDREN 



opponents   and   understand   their   case�察  �quite   commonly   respect   and   like 

them�察�and always learn something from them。 

     Here�察 �again�察  �as   at   so   many  points�察  �we   come   up   against   the   abuse   of 

schools     to  keep    people    in  ignorance     and   error�察  �so  that  they   may    be 

incapable of successful revolt against their industrial slavery。                 The most 

important   simple   fundamental   economic   truth   to   impress   on   a   child   in 

complicated   civilizations   like   ours   is   the   truth   that   whoever   consumes 

goods or services without producing by personal effort the equivalent of 

what   he   or   she   consumes�察  �inflicts   on   the   community  precisely   the   same 

injury that a thief produces�察�and would�察�in any honest State�察�be treated as a 

thief�察�however full his or her pockets might be of money made by other 

people。      The   nation   that   first   teaches   its   children   that   truth�察  �instead   of 

flogging them if they discover it for themselves�察�may have to fight all the 

slaves of all the other nations to begin with�察�but it will beat them as easily 

as an unburdened man with his hands free and with all his energies in full 

play can beat an invalid who has to carry another invalid on his back。 

     This�察�however�察�is not an evil produced by the denial of children's rights�察�

nor is it inherent   in the nature   of schools。         I   mention   it   only  because   it 

would be folly to call for a reform of our schools without taking account 

of the corrupt resistance which awaits the reformer。 

     A word must also be said about the opposition to reform of the vested 

interest of the classical and coercive schoolmaster。               He�察�poor wretch�察�has 

no other means of livelihood�察�and reform would leave him as a workman 

is now left when he is superseded by a machine。                 He had therefore better 

do what he can to get the workman compensated�察�so as to make the public 

familiar with the idea of compensation before his own turn comes。 



                                                30 


´ Page 31´

                        A TREATISE ON PARENTS AND CHILDREN 



                             Taboo in Schools 



     The  suppression   of   economic   knowledge�察 �disastrous   as   it   is�察  �is   quite 

intelligible�察�its corrupt motive being as clear as the motive of a burglar for 

concealing his jemmy from a policeman。                 But the other great suppression 

in our   schools�察�the suppression of   the subject of sex�察�is   a case   of taboo。 

In mankind�察�the lower the type�察�and the less cultivated the mind�察�the less 

courage   there   is   to   face   important   subjects   objectively。     The   ablest   and 

most   highly   cultivated   people   continually   discuss   religion�察  �politics�察  �and 

sex�此   �it   is   hardly   an   exaggeration   to   say   that   they   discuss   nothing   else 

with    fully´awakened        interest。   Commoner         and   less   cultivated    people�察�

even when they form societies for discussion�察�make a rule that politics and 

religion   are   not   to   be   mentioned�察  �and   take   it   for   granted   that   no   decent 

person     would     attempt    to  discuss    sex。   The     three   subjects   are   feared 

because they rouse the crude passions which call for furious gratification 

in    murder     and   rapine    at  worst�察   �and�察  �at   best�察  �lead   to  quarrels    and 

undesirable states of consciousness。 

     Even when this excuse of bad manners�察�ill temper�察�and brutishness ��for 

that is what it comes to�� compels us to accept it from those adults among 

whom political and theological discussion does as a matter of fact lead to 

the drawing of knives and pistols�察�and sex discussion leads to obscenity�察�it 

has no application to children except as an imperative reason for training 

them to respect other people's opinions�察�and to insist on respect for their 

own in these as in other important matters which are equally dangerous�此�

for example�察�money。 And in any case there are decisive reasons�察�superior�察�

like   the   reasons   for   suspending   conventional   reticences   between   doctor 

and    patient�察  �to  all  considerations      of  mere    decorum�察    �for  giving    proper 

instruction   in   the   facts   of   sex。  Those   who   object   to   it   ��not   counting 

coarse people who thoughtlessly seize every opportunity of affecting and 

parading   a   fictitious   delicacy��   are�察  �in   effect�察  �advocating   ignorance   as   a 

safeguard   against   precocity。       If   ignorance   were   practicable   there   would 

be something to be said for it up to the age at which ignorance is a danger 

instead of a safeguard。        Even as it is�察�it seems undesirable that any special 

emphasis should be given to the subject�察�whether by way of delicacy and 



                                                31 


´ Page 32´

                       A TREATISE ON PARENTS AND CHILDREN 



poetry or too impressive warning。           But the plain fact is that in refusing to 

allow   the   child   to   be   taught   by   qualified   unrelated   elders   ��the   parents 

shrink from the lesson�察�even   when they are otherwise qualified�察  �because 

their own relation to the child makes the subject impossible between them�� 

we are virtually arranging to have our children taught by other children in 

guilty   secrets   and   unclean   jests。    And   that   settles   the   question   for   all 

sensible people。 

     The   dogmatic   objection�察  �the   sheer   instinctive   taboo   which   rules   the 

subject out altogether as indecent�察�has no age limit。              It means that at no 

matter what age a woman consents to a proposal of marriage�察�she should 

do so in ignorance of the relation she is undertaking。              When this actually 

happens ��and apparently it does happen oftener than would seem possible�� 

a horrible fraud is being practiced on both the man and the woman。                   He is 

led to believe that she knows what she is promising�察�and that he is in no 

danger of finding himself bound to a woman to whom he is eugenically 

antipathetic。     She contemplates nothing but such affectionate relations as 

may exist between her and her nearest kinsmen�察�and has no knowledge of 

the condition which�察�if not foreseen�察�must come as an amazing revelation 

and a dangerous shock�察�ending possibly in the discovery that the marriage 

has been an irreparable mistake。          Nothing can justify such a risk。          There 

may be people incapable of understanding that the right to know all there 

is to know about oneself is a natural human right that sweeps away all the 

pretences of others to tamper with one's consciousness in order to produce 

what they choose to consider a good character。               But they must here bow 

to the plain mischievousness of entrapping people into contracts on which 

the happiness of their whole lives depends without letting them know what 

they are undertaking。 



                                               32 


´ Page 33´

                       A TREATISE ON PARENTS AND CHILDREN 



              Alleged Novelties in Modern 

                                     Schools 



     There is just one more nuisance to be disposed of before I come to the 

positive    side   of  my   case。    I  mean     the  person    who    tells  me   that  my 

schooldays belong to a bygone order of educational ideas and institutions�察�

and   that   schools   are   not   now   a   bit   like   my   old   school。   I   reply�察  �with   Sir 

Walter   Raleigh�察    �by   calling   on   my   soul   to  give  this   statement    the  lie。 

Some   years   ago   I   lectured   in   Oxford   on   the   subject   of   Education。    A 

friend   to   whom   I   mentioned   my   intention   said�察   �You   know   nothing   of 

modern education�此        �schools are not now what they were when you were a 

boy。;    I   immediately   procured   the   time   sheets   of   half   a   dozen   modern 

schools�察�and found�察 �as I  expected�察�that they might   all have  been my  old 

school�此    �there   was   no   real   difference。  I   may   mention�察 �too�察  �that   I   have 

visited   modern   schools�察  �and   observed   that   there   is   a   tendency   to   hang 

printed    pictures    in  an  untidy    and   soulless   manner     on   the  walls�察  �and 

occasionally      to   display   on   the   mantel´shelf     a   deplorable    glass    case 

containing certain objects which might possibly�察�if placed in the hands of 

the pupils�察�give them some practical experience of the weight of a pound 

and the length of an inch。          And sometimes a scoundrel who has rifled a 

bird's nest or killed a harmless snake encourages the children to go and do 

likewise     by   putting   his  victims    into  an  imitation    nest   and   bottle  and 

exhibiting   them  as   aids   to   ;Nature   study。;    A  suggestion   that   Nature   is 

worth study would certainly have staggered my schoolmasters�察�so perhaps 

I may admit a gleam of progress here。             But as any child who attempted to 

handl

卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��1�� 家��2��

低辛嬬浪散議